Season's Savings | ₹5/mo for 3 months

₹199/month after first 3 months. Renews automatically. Terms apply.
Someone Wicked This Way Comes cover art

Someone Wicked This Way Comes

Someone Wicked This Way Comes

Written by: Angie
Listen for free

About this listen
This podcast is about Holly Staker, an 11 YO girl from Waukegan, IL who was brutally raped and killed while babysitting. Ten weeks after Holly was killed, Juan Rivera, a local young man was arrested. Juan allegedly confessed to the murder. He was tried on three separate occasions and was found guilty each time. He would later be exonerated. Over the years, Juan has received a lot of attention, but Holly and her family, and friends have been lost in the noise. This podcast is to shine a light on Holly and to get justice which has long been denied. justice4hstaker@gmail.comAngie True Crime
Episodes
  • Confession Collector
    Nov 10 2026

    What happens when detectives becomes more interested in obtaining confessions than uncovering the truth?

    The Confession Collector examines the false confessions out of Cook County and Lake County, Illinois and the officers who were involved in those confessions.

    I will also examine the investigative methods of former Lake County detective Lou Tessmann, whose online biography still claims responsibility for obtaining more than 80 homicide confessions even though the men he claims obtaining confessions from have since been exonerated.

    Brutal murders. Innocent men convicted. And investigations in which confessions and coerced statements became more important than forensic evidence. And victims who have never received justice.

    At the center of it all is the unanswered question: Who murdered 11-year-old Holly Staker, and did the relentless pursuit of a confession allow her real killer to escape justice?

    Show More Show Less
    1 hr and 2 mins
  • Strange Happenings: The Found Knife and the Voit Hightops
    Jul 7 2026

    A knife that was found and then forgotten. A pair of shoes that didn't exist in the US until after Holly's murder contained DNA that raises questions no one has been able to answer.

    What would you think if I told you that police recovered a knife from the property immediately next door to where Holly Staker was murdered but Rivera's attorneys didn't learn about it until more than twenty years later, and after the police destroyed it?

    Or that investigators announced they had found Holly's blood on a pair of black Voit high-top shoes they claimed Rivera wore during the murder only to quietly walk away from those shoes after the defense uncovered records showing they weren't even available for sale in the United States until after Holly was killed?

    And then there's this. Years later, those same shoes were tested again. The results didn't answer the questions. They created even bigger ones. Because the testing reportedly detected DNA associated with the still-unidentified male linked to Holly's murder.

    How does that happen?

    How does biological evidence end up on a pair of shoes that prosecutors abandoned and records suggest couldn't have been worn during the crime?

    In this episode, we're going to walk through the evidence, the documents, the court records, and the timeline. Because once you see how all of these pieces fit together, or more appropriately don't, you may find yourself asking the same question I did:

    What really happened here?

    Show More Show Less
    42 mins
  • Wicked - Comes in Many Ways
    Jun 2 2026

    Two child murders, Holly Staker and Jeanine Nicarico, end up telling the same chilling story: once police pick a suspect, the system stops asking who did it and starts creating a narrative to prove that person did. Both cases lean on shaky human statements, false confessions, shifting stories, and admitted lies, while ignoring evidence that doesn’t fit, and evidence that may have been planted. Even when DNA raises doubts in Rivera’s case, and even when another man confesses in the Nicarico case, the prosecutions push forward. Families trust the system because the alternative is unbearable: if the system is wrong, the real killer is still out there. Wicked doesn’t just describe the men who killed Holly Staker and Jeanine Nicarico. It describes the ones who let their killers slip away, while innocent men were locked in cages for crimes they never committed.

    Show More Show Less
    1 hr and 1 min
adbl_web_anon_alc_button_suppression_t1
No reviews yet