A poltergeist that earns the nickname “Mr. Nobody.” A small-town double murder where the evidence doesn’t just go cold, it vanishes. A dream that sends searchers into the bush and leads to a body no one expected to find. We line these stories up side by side and ask the question that keeps pulling us back to the strange: what do you do when the facts stop being enough, but the witnesses, the patterns, and the timing still won’t let go?

First, we head to West Yorkshire and the Black Monk of Pontefract, one of the most debated UK poltergeist hauntings. We walk through the early reports that feel uniquely unsettling, like mysterious pools of water forming in front of people and a cloud of white dust falling onto a seated grandmother. Then we follow the escalation into banging, lights, a shadowy figure, and claims of physical harm centered on a teenager, including the infamous account of being dragged up the stairs. We also talk through the uncomfortable tension between skepticism and lived experience, especially when multiple witnesses step forward and the family never seems to profit from the story.

Next, we dig into the 1948 Mary Jane Reed and Stanley Scridla case in Oregon, Illinois. The timeline is brutal, the details are odd, and the later discovery of an empty case file raises the kind of questions that stick with you for years. From there, we pivot to dreams, consciousness, and a case where an Aboriginal elder’s dream leads investigators to a different victim, widening the tragedy and the mystery at once. We close by zooming out to modern spirituality and why witchcraft, tarot, and ritual have become more visible and more commercialized across the US and beyond.

If you like paranormal podcasts, true crime mysteries, poltergeist cases, and the psychology of belief, hit play, then subscribe, share with a friend, and leave a review so more people can find the Midnight Council.

Support the show

To watch video episodes of The Haunted Minds Podcast, join and live commentate during recordings, or just hang out with other paranormal lovers - become a member of The Midnight Council private community at mosthauntedinc.com.