What did Jordan Peterson get wrong? Why are so many people converting to Orthodoxy? Is AI demonic? Pastor and YouTuber Paul VanderKlay joins Dan Leibrandt to talk about the meaning crisis, ritual, the Orthodox moment, AI chatbots competing with the church, and why in-person community matters more than ever.
Paul VanderKlay is the pastor of Living Stones Christian Reformed Church in Sacramento, California. Since 2017, when he began commenting on Jordan Peterson's Bible lectures, he has made thousands of YouTube videos and conversations, and he writes a Substack, On Life and the Christian Faith. He is also the originator of Estuary, a growing network of in-person conversation groups.
Dan and Paul start with what Jordan Peterson got wrong, from his move to The Daily Wire to why he still won't say he believes in Christ, and how the meaning crisis that John Vervaeke named sent young men looking for church. Paul explains why people can't live without meaning, why sports can sustain you but can't take you all the way, and why ritual is the foundation of a civilization, with help from Tom Brady, The Truman Show and Jonathan Pageau.
Then they turn to the rise of Orthodox Christianity in America, from the seeker movement and the emerging church to the Young, Restless, Reformed. They talk about AI chatbots competing with pastors, whether AI is demonic, what C.S. Lewis's The Screwtape Letters says about distraction, and why we don't wrestle against flesh and blood. They finish with Estuary's simple conversation protocol and why in-person community goes deeper than anything online.
The Dan Leibrandt Show is about navigating the future as a Christian and what it means to stay human. Subscribe for more conversations like this.
CHAPTERS
00:00 What Jordan Peterson got wrong
02:18 Why Jordan Peterson won't say he believes in Christ
05:29 Is the meaning crisis getting better or worse
09:00 Can sports give your life meaning
14:01 Why humans need ritual
24:00 Why so many people are converting to Orthodoxy
34:03 AI chatbots vs the church
40:31 Is AI demonic
46:50 Has Paul seen demonic possession
49:25 Why we don't wrestle against flesh and blood
54:26 Estuary's four-step conversation protocol
57:48 Why in-person community beats online
1:01:27 The future of the church in America
1:04:04 Where to find Paul VanderKlay and Estuary
FOLLOW PAUL VANDERKLAY
YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@PaulVanderKlay
Substack: https://paulvanderklay.substack.com
Podcast: https://paulvanderklay.podbean.com
Estuary: https://www.estuaryhub.com
This Little Corner: https://thislittlecorner.net
Living Stones CRC: https://www.livingstonescrc.com
FOLLOW DAN
X: https://x.com/danleibrandt
Website: https://danleibrandt.com
MUSIC
Music licensed through Soundstripe.
Code: 4276LM38TFHFJBDU
SCRIPTURE
Scripture quotations are from the ESV® Bible (The Holy Bible, English Standard Version®), © 2001 by Crossway, a publishing ministry of Good News Publishers. Used by permission. All rights reserved.
#JordanPeterson #Orthodoxy #AI #Church #Christianity