Episodes

  • Episode 18: Newcastle United 2020/21 - Steve Bruce, Joe Willock and the Road to the Takeover
    Nov 18 2026

    Newcastle United's difficult 2020/21 season under Steve Bruce, Joe Willock's remarkable loan spell and the build-up to the Saudi-backed takeover are the focus as Jamie Smith, Simon Cahill and David Hutchinson return for the final instalment of their international break specials. The trio revisit football behind closed doors, compare the pre-takeover squad with today's Newcastle United and look ahead to the return of Bruno Guimarães with Arsenal.

    The 2020/21 campaign was a strange time to be a Newcastle supporter. With St James' Park largely empty due to Covid restrictions, Mike Ashley still in charge and Steve Bruce overseeing some desperately uninspiring football, the connection between supporters and their club was arguably at its lowest point.

    Simon takes us back through the season, from the arrival of Callum Wilson and Ryan Fraser to the struggles of a side relying heavily on Allan Saint-Maximin for attacking inspiration. Despite spending much of the campaign uncomfortably close to the relegation places, Newcastle eventually finished 12th, thanks in no small part to Joe Willock's extraordinary impact after joining on loan from Arsenal.

    There's also a moving personal story from Simon about his family's experiences during lockdown, providing a reminder that football was only one part of an extraordinary period in everyone's lives.

    The discussion then turns to the present. Has Newcastle's squad improved as much as it should have since the takeover? Are there players from Bruce's team who would strengthen today's starting eleven? And how much patience should supporters have with the club's latest recruits?

    With the international break finally ending, there's a roundup of Newcastle players representing their countries before attention switches to Arsenal's visit and the potentially awkward reception awaiting former Magpies favourite Bruno Guimarães.

    Plenty of nostalgia, disagreement and the usual irreverent humour in another edition of The Mag Pod.


    Key Moments

    00:17 – Introduction and international break banter

    03:56 – Revisiting Newcastle's 2020/21 season

    08:55 – Summer transfers and Callum Wilson's arrival

    12:55 – Newcastle's league position and relegation concerns

    14:16 – Watching Newcastle during Covid lockdown

    20:48 – Assessing Steve Bruce's Newcastle squad

    24:59 – The disastrous run of results under Bruce

    27:32 – Joe Willock's arrival and Simon's personal story

    31:28 – Willock's impact and the return to St James' Park

    34:20 – Heroes and villains of the 2020/21 season

    36:58 – The takeover saga and Eddie Howe's arrival

    40:44 – Comparing Newcastle's pre-takeover and current squads

    49:07 – Newcastle players on international duty

    52:35 – Arsenal preview and Bruno Guimarães' return

    54:36 – Final thoughts and sign-off

    55:22 – Post-show blooper

    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

    Show More Show Less
    56 mins
  • Episode 17: Newcastle United’s 2015/16 Relegation - Lessons from the Past
    Nov 16 2026

    Jamie Smith, Simon Cahill and David Hutchinson revisit Newcastle United’s 2015/16 relegation season, examining the failures under Steve McClaren, the arrival of Rafa Benítez and whether there are lessons to be learned amid the concerns surrounding the current 2026/27 campaign. The lads also discuss Newcastle United Women’s derby draw with Sunderland and the controversial travel restrictions for the upcoming Tyne-Wear derby.

    In the second of three episodes this week, Hutch takes us through another particularly forgettable chapter in Newcastle United’s history. From a disappointing start to the season and a recruitment policy that prioritised potential over experience, to a divided dressing room and a lack of leadership on the pitch, there was no shortage of contributing factors to United’s downfall.

    There’s a look back at the performances of Georginio Wijnaldum, Aleksandar Mitrović, Fabricio Coloccini and Moussa Sissoko, as well as some personal memories of the campaign, including a frustrating afternoon at Old Trafford and a particularly miserable pre-Christmas encounter with Aston Villa.

    Could an earlier appointment of Rafa Benítez have saved Newcastle from relegation? The lads discuss the importance of knowing when to make a managerial change, whilst considering the differences between the Newcastle United of a decade ago and the club today.

    There’s also an assessment of the increasingly congested Premier League table, the importance of experienced players in a transitional squad and the heroes and villains of the 2015/16 season.

    Naturally, a controversial Sergio Agüero goal brings about another argument between Jamie and Simon over the merits of VAR, with all the maturity listeners have come to expect.

    Another nostalgic look at a period Newcastle supporters would rather forget, but one which offers plenty of talking points given the challenges facing United today.


    Key Moments

    00:18 – Introduction and Nando’s controversy

    02:49 – Newcastle United Women’s derby draw

    04:17 – Tyne-Wear derby travel restrictions

    06:41 – Newcastle United Women’s promotion prospects

    07:52 – Revisiting the 2015/16 relegation season

    10:13 – The appointment of Steve McClaren

    14:36 – Comparing the Premier League tables

    17:52 – Defensive weaknesses and dressing room divisions

    20:10 – Leaving a managerial change too late

    22:31 – Transfer policy and summer signings

    24:05 – An ageing squad and emerging leaders

    26:01 – Memories of Old Trafford

    28:42 – The run of results that derailed the season

    30:23 – Rafa Benítez and what could have been

    33:38 – Heroes of the relegation season

    34:09 – Villains of the relegation season

    36:48 – Lessons for Newcastle United today

    38:53 – Personal memories of 2015/16

    40:19 – Sergio Agüero’s offside goal and the VAR debate

    43:33 – Looking ahead to the next episode

    45:54 – Mag out

    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

    Show More Show Less
    47 mins
  • Episode 16: Newcastle United 2008/09: Chaos, Keegan and Relegation
    Nov 13 2026

    Newcastle United's disastrous 2008/09 relegation season is back under the

    microscope as Jamie Smith, Simon Cahill and David Hutchinson revisit the chaos of

    Kevin Keegan's departure, Mike Ashley's ownership and Alan Shearer's desperate

    rescue mission. With Newcastle struggling for consistency in the 2026/27 Premier

    League season, the lads ask whether history offers any lessons for the current

    squad – and whether today's concerns really compare with one of the club's most

    turbulent campaigns.

    The international break provides a welcome breather from Newcastle's league

    struggles, and there's time for a typically entertaining roundup of international action,

    including Dan Burn and Lewis Hall representing England and Yoane Wissa finding

    the net for DR Congo. Managerial upheaval elsewhere in the Premier League also

    provides plenty of ammunition, particularly Manchester United's latest troubles.

    Then it's back to 2008/09, when optimism surrounding Keegan's return quickly

    unravelled into protests, questionable transfers and a succession of managerial

    changes. Jamie recalls the toxic atmosphere following Keegan's exit, the

    controversial roles of Dennis Wise and Tony Jimenez, and the extraordinary

    collection of players who somehow ended up relegated.

    From Shay Given's departure and Joe Kinnear's eventful spell to Shearer's arrival

    with just eight matches remaining, the discussion explores where Newcastle's

    season went wrong. There's also time to remember some miserable away trips,

    controversial refereeing decisions and the players who eventually helped restore

    pride in the Championship.

    Crucially, the lads compare that relegated side with Newcastle's current squad,

    examining leadership, creativity, commitment and the importance of stability. Could

    the same mistakes happen again, or are today's foundations considerably stronger?

    With more historical comparisons planned throughout the international break, this

    opening instalment combines painful memories, plenty of gallows humour and a

    surprisingly reassuring perspective on Newcastle United's present predicament.

    Key Moments

    00:17 – Introduction and the international break

    04:41 – Premier League managerial departures

    08:40 – Introducing the relegation season comparisons

    09:47 – Newcastle United's 2008/09 season

    13:29 – Mike Ashley, Kevin Keegan and early optimism

    15:47 – Opening results and Keegan's departure

    16:48 – Hull City, protests and the Cockney Mafia

    18:36 – Comparing 2008/09 with Newcastle's current season

    20:03 – The quality of Newcastle's relegated squad

    22:04 – Shay Given and James Milner departures

    24:11 – Charles N'Zogbia and Joe Kinnear

    28:28 – Alan Shearer's relegation rescue mission

    29:35 – Middlesbrough, Fulham and Aston Villa

    31:59 – The Championship bounce-back

    32:38 – Heroes of the 2008/09 season

    34:09 – Dennis Wise, Tony Jimenez and transfer failures

    35:52 – Memories of a miserable season

    37:34 – Lessons in managerial stability

    38:37 – Comparing the squads then and now

    42:42 – What really caused Newcastle's relegation?

    47:24 – Is the current Newcastle side better equipped to survive?

    49:01 – Coming next: 2015/16 and 2020/21

    51:21 – Final recording outtake

    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

    Show More Show Less
    51 mins
  • Episode 15: Fulham Frustration, Newcastle United’s Season Report Card and Relegation Fears
    Nov 9 2026

    Newcastle United's frustrating draw at Fulham, a worrying lack of goals and an

    increasingly uncomfortable Premier League position dominate Episode 10 of The

    Mag Pod. Jamie Smith is joined by Simon Cahill and David Hutchinson to assess the

    Magpies; latest performance before delivering their quarter-season report cards,

    picking Newcastle's standout players and signings, and debating whether this

    campaign could yet end in European qualification or a relegation battle.

    The 1-1 draw at Craven Cottage provides plenty to discuss. Jacob Murphy's

    spectacular strike earns praise, but Fulham's equaliser, Harvey Barnes; missed

    opportunities and Dan Burn's controversially disallowed goal leave the lads

    wondering whether Newcastle have thrown away another valuable two points.

    There's particular concern about Newcastle's attacking options. With goals proving

    difficult to come by, the panel questions whether the current forwards can provide

    what the team needs, while Hutch delivers a particularly unforgiving assessment of

    Harvey Barnes. Murphy's celebration also comes under the microscope, prompting a

    wider discussion about supporters; expectations and the criticism facing established

    members of the squad.

    With ten Premier League matches played, it's time for the first proper assessment of

    Newcastle's season. Jamie, Simon and Hutch reveal their grades, nominate their

    highlights, choose their best summer signings and identify their players of the

    season so far. Lewis Hall, Sean Steur and Horníček all feature in the

    conversation.

    Looking ahead, the mood ranges from cautious optimism to outright pessimism.

    Could Newcastle recover sufficiently to challenge for European football, or is a

    relegation battle becoming a genuine possibility? And with Sunderland looming on

    the fixture list, there's plenty of anxiety about what the coming months might bring.

    There's the usual humour, disagreements and increasingly desperate attempts to

    find positives, as the lads consider what supporters can realistically hope for from the

    rest of the season.

    Key Moments

    00:18 – Introduction and the international break

    01:18 – Fulham 1-1 Newcastle United

    06:09 – Jacob Murphy's spectacular goal

    07:10 – Newcastle's striker problems

    11:39 – Dan Burn's disallowed goal and VAR controversy


    16:28 – Jacob Murphy's celebration and criticism from supporters

    20:35 – Fulham: A point gained or two dropped?

    23:39 – Premier League position and Sunderland concerns

    27:11 – Newcastle's quarter-season review

    27:45 – Grading the season so far

    28:56 – Highlights of the season

    31:21 – Best summer signing

    33:47 – Player of the season so far

    35:13 – What is there to look forward to?

    39:19 – Best-case scenario for Newcastle

    41:16 – Worst-case scenario and relegation fears

    45:45 – Assessing Newcastle's transitional season

    46:28 – International break plans and upcoming episodes

    48:32 – Hutch's Harvey Barnes apology

    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

    Show More Show Less
    49 mins
  • Episode 14: Everton Misery, Newcastle's Transfer Failings and the Blame Game
    Nov 4 2026

    Newcastle United's miserable run against Everton, growing relegation fears and questions over the club's transfer spending dominate this week's Mag Pod. Jamie Smith is joined by Simon Cahill and David Hutchinson to pick through another dismal night at St James' Park, the disappointment of exiting the Carabao Cup and the increasingly uncomfortable debate over who is responsible for Newcastle's dramatic decline.

    The lads begin with Monday night's 1-0 home defeat to Everton, a performance that left supporters frustrated long before the final whistle. With misplaced passes, little attacking threat and a tactical system that appears to be causing more problems than it solves, there's plenty to discuss about what has gone wrong on the pitch.

    The conversation also turns to the League Cup exit and whether losing that familiar source of hope has made Newcastle's Premier League struggles feel even worse. With no European football to provide a distraction, just how worried should supporters be about the possibility of relegation?

    Then comes the blame game. Jamie brings some uncomfortable figures to the table concerning Newcastle's recruitment, including £547 million spent on 14 signings since May 2025, with only four of those players starting against Everton. The panel debates the quality of the recruitment, the contribution of established players and whether the current manager is getting enough from the squad at his disposal.

    There's also a discussion about the opportunities being given to younger players, the growing pressure from the stands and the possibility of another managerial change. Could Rafa Benitez really be an option again, or would that simply create another set of problems?

    Finally, attention turns to the upcoming trip to Fulham and whether Newcastle can find a much-needed response.

    It's a frustrated, occasionally heated and typically humorous Mag Pod, with three supporters trying to make sense of a season that's heading in the wrong direction.

    Key Moments

    00:17 – Introduction and listener shout-outs

    05:30 – Newcastle's home defeat to Everton

    11:53 – Everton's recent record against Newcastle

    14:26 – Tactical problems and midfield struggles

    18:30 – Carabao Cup exit and the worsening mood

    23:24 – Young players and missed opportunities

    25:16 – Relegation fears

    27:54 – The blame game begins

    29:42 – Newcastle's £547 million transfer spending

    31:21 – Recruitment failures and attacking problems

    34:42 – Are the players to blame?

    36:10 – Recruitment decisions and club responsibility

    40:51 – How long should the manager be given?

    44:27 – Could Rafa Benitez return?

    48:28 – Who deserves the most blame?

    50:12 – Fulham preview and predictions

    53:34 – Closing thoughts

    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

    Show More Show Less
    54 mins
  • Episode 13 - Palace Honours as Fab and Dan Return, Howe Considers Poisoned Chalice and Double Ev Ahead
    Oct 27 2026

    The Mag Pod Ep 13 – Newcastle United Beat Palace, Schar and Burn Deliver, and Eddie Howe to Man Utd?

    Episode Summary – 53 Minutes

    Newcastle United’s 2-0 victory away to Crystal Palace, the return of Fabian Schär and Dan Burn at centre-back, and speculation linking Eddie Howe with the Manchester United job dominate this week’s Mag Pod. Jamie Smith is joined by Simon Cahill and David Hutchinson to discuss a much-needed Premier League win, whether Newcastle have finally found some defensive stability, and what lies ahead as the Magpies prepare to face Everton twice in the space of a few days.

    The mood is considerably brighter after Newcastle's win at Selhurst Park, although the three hosts have rather different experiences of watching the match. Simon admits to sleeping through much of the first half, while Hutch struggles to find a television showing the game during his holiday in Turkey. Thankfully, Newcastle's second-half performance gives everyone something positive to discuss.

    The decision to restore Schar and Burn to the starting line-up comes under the spotlight, with the pair bringing experience, organisation and composure to a defence that has struggled this season. There's also praise for Jacob Murphy, Nick Woltemade's replacement William Osula, Nico González and goalkeeper Horníček, alongside a typically chaotic Newcastle United history quiz about the club's oldest Premier League players.

    Attention then turns to the wider league picture. Are Newcastle supporters right to remain cautious despite the victory? Would a 14th-place finish still represent an acceptable outcome? And what should fans make of Sunderland's struggles ahead of the next Tyne-Wear derby?

    The conversation moves to Manchester United, where Eddie Howe is being linked with replacing Michael Carrick. The lads consider how Newcastle's transfer restrictions affected Howe's time on Tyneside, imagine the squad he might have built with greater financial freedom, and debate whether Old Trafford would be the right destination for their former manager.

    Finally, there's League Cup trivia, a look at Everton's cup history and a discussion of Newcastle's upcoming cup and league double-header against the Toffees. Can the Magpies build on Sunday's result and keep their hopes of another trophy alive?

    Key Moments

    00:28 – Introduction

    01:03 – Crystal Palace 0-2 Newcastle United

    03:48 – Watching Newcastle from abroad

    08:12 – Schar and Burn restore defensive stability

    11:02 – Newcastle's oldest Premier League players

    18:22 – The future of Newcastle's defence

    20:08 – Newcastle's league position and season expectations

    21:42 – Sunderland's struggles and the upcoming derby

    24:03 – Manchester United and the Eddie Howe speculation

    26:25 – How Newcastle's transfer restrictions affected Eddie Howe

    28:34 – The Newcastle team Eddie Howe might have built

    32:37 – Could Howe rebuild Manchester United?

    35:05 – Would Newcastle fans want Howe at Old Trafford?

    38:24 – Mag Pod trivia: Everton and the League Cup

    41:24 – Everton's cup ambitions

    44:08 – Newcastle's chances of another League Cup triumph

    47:08 – Everton twice in a week: which match matters more?

    49:22 – Predictions for the Everton double-header

    51:11 – Final thoughts and looking ahead

    53:01 – Closing remarks

    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

    Show More Show Less
    54 mins
  • Episode 12 – Newcastle United’s Villa Misery, Musical Meltdown and Football’s Unfair Playing Field
    Oct 18 2026

    Newcastle United’s disappointing defeat to Aston Villa, the controversial new version of Blaydon Races at St James’ Park and the growing divide between the Premier League’s established elite and the chasing pack dominate this week’s Mag Pod. Jamie Smith is joined by Simon Cahill and David Hutchinson for a lively discussion of Newcastle’s worrying form, the future of matchday atmosphere and whether the financial rules are preventing clubs like Newcastle from challenging at the top.

    Fresh from the Villa match, the trio reflect on another miserable performance and ask an uncomfortable question: would supporters now happily accept 14th place and no cup success? With Newcastle struggling to create chances, defensive errors becoming increasingly costly and new players still finding their feet, there are genuine concerns about where the season might be heading.

    Away from the football, attention turns to the re-recorded Blaydon Races and whether a slower, more atmospheric rendition really belongs at St James’ Park. That opens up a thoroughly entertaining debate about Newcastle United chants, from the enduring appeal of Local Hero to the songs that inspire supporters and those that drive them absolutely mad. Hutch has particularly strong feelings about one old favourite.

    The discussion then moves into more serious territory, prompted by an article on The Mag examining how football’s biggest clubs established their dominance. From Liverpool’s rise to the modern financial restrictions facing Newcastle, the lads consider whether the current system protects established powers and what that means for the future of competitive football.

    Finally, attention turns to Crystal Palace away, with the panel searching for reasons to be optimistic ahead of another potentially difficult afternoon.

    It's another episode combining frustration, football history, terrace nostalgia and plenty of gallows humour as the lads attempt to make sense of life supporting Newcastle United.

    Key Moments

    00:17 – Introduction and Aston Villa reaction

    01:14 – Would you accept 14th place?

    04:28 – Newcastle's attacking and defensive problems

    10:24 – Who is to blame?

    14:19 – Refereeing controversy against Villa

    16:55 – The new Blaydon Races recording

    19:58 – Matchday atmosphere at St James’ Park

    23:58 – Newcastle chants and terrace favourites

    32:56 – The Mag and football's financial divide

    36:49 – Can Newcastle challenge the established elite?

    40:18 – The future of football and breakaway leagues

    45:17 – Financial restrictions and competitive fairness

    49:13 – Crystal Palace away preview and predictions

    51:41 – Final thoughts and sign-off

    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

    Show More Show Less
    53 mins
  • Episode 11: The Mag Pod Special - Newcastle United and Aston Villa. Rivalry, Transfers and the Man City Fallout
    Oct 15 2026

    Special guest Chris Budd from My Old Man Said joins Jamie, Simon, and Hutch for Episode 11.


    Check out My Old Man Said: https://myoldmansaid.com

    Listen to the Villa Podcast: https://myoldmansaid.com/aston-villa-podcast/


    Newcastle United and Aston Villa's growing rivalry, the challenges of rebuilding two

    ambitious Premier League clubs and the potential fallout from Manchester City's

    financial charges take centre stage in this special crossover edition of The Mag Pod.

    Joined by Chris Budd from Aston Villa podcast My Old Man Said, the lads look

    ahead to Saturday's meeting at St James'; Park, revisit the clubs'; shared history and

    ask whether either side can break through the Premier League's established

    hierarchy.

    There's plenty of common ground between Newcastle and Villa, from difficult

    ownership eras and Championship football to European adventures and long-

    awaited silverware. But there's also some unfinished business, particularly around

    Newcastle's relegation at Villa Park in 2009 and the bad blood that followed.

    The conversation moves into the modern era, comparing Eddie Howe's Newcastle

    with Unai Emery's Villa and exploring how both clubs have been forced to adapt

    following significant departures. With wealthy owners but financial regulations

    restricting their spending, are Newcastle and Villa being prevented from building on

    their success?

    That leads into a lively debate about Manchester City's financial case, the fairness of

    Premier League spending rules and what appropriate punishments might look like if

    wrongdoing is established. The panel considers whether the current system protects

    the traditional elite and whether a major shake-up could create opportunities for

    ambitious challengers.

    Attention eventually turns to Saturday's Newcastle v Aston Villa fixture. Chris offers

    an insight into Villa's rebuilt squad, Emery's evolving tactics and the players

    Newcastle supporters should watch, while the lads weigh up home advantage,

    European commitments and the unpredictability of two teams in transition.

    There's also time to discuss what success might look like for both clubs this season,

    the value of European football and why winning trophies means so much more than

    simply balancing the books.

    A good-humoured crossover with plenty of football debate, shared frustrations and a

    healthy dose of Newcastle–Villa rivalry.

    Key Moments

    00:22 – Introduction and My Old Man Said

    04:45 – Supporting Newcastle and Villa through the bad times

    07:23 – Newcastle United v Aston Villa: A shared history

    08:30 – Newcastle's 2009 relegation at Villa Park

    12:22 – Relegation, Championship football and rebuilding

    16:18 – Newcastle and Villa's modern resurgence

    16:44 – Eddie Howe v Unai Emery

    20:42 – Could Villa lose Unai Emery?

    24:08 – Summer departures and rebuilding both squads

    28:00 – Financial rules and the Premier League hierarchy

    33:28 – Manchester City's financial charges

    38:11 – The traditional elite and football's changing landscape

    42:31 – Sympathy for Manchester City supporters?

    46:02 – What punishment should Manchester City face?

    51:08 – Newcastle United v Aston Villa preview

    52:31 – Villa's form and match predictions

    55:23 – Aston Villa's players to watch

    58:29 – Newcastle's home advantage

    59:26 – Villa's ambitions for the season

    01:01:58 – Champions League, Europa League and the value of trophies

    01:05:24 – Final thoughts and sign-off

    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

    Show More Show Less
    1 hr and 8 mins