Season's Savings | ₹5/mo for 3 months

₹199/month after first 3 months. Renews automatically. Terms apply.
The Path Went Chilly cover art

The Path Went Chilly

The Path Went Chilly

Written by: Robin Jules Ashley TPWC
Listen for free

About this listen
Welcome to The Path Went Chilly where Robin Warder from The Trail Went Cold will discuss his favorite cases with friends Dr. Jules from Riddle Me That! True Crime and Criminologist Dr. Ashley Wellman. This will be a deep dive and a fresh perspective, join us as we descend deeper down the rabbit hole & examine these unsolved cases with compassionate consideration towards the families left behind.Copyright Robin Jules Ashley TPWC True Crime
Episodes
  • Shannon Green: Dewayne Bell & John Reneer Statement Analysis Pt. Two
    Nov 12 2026
    Support the show: Patreon.com/julesandashleyPatreon.com/thetrailwentcoldBelow is the transcript with my notes in case you would like to follow along: Transcript of Quotes – 14 NEWS Investigation Source material: 14 NEWS (WFIE) article screenshots. All quoted wording preserved exactly as it appeared. Non-quote narrative text omitted. Ordered as closely as possible to the chronological sequence of events. John Reneer on why he recorded the conversation (two days after Shannon Green’s disappearance) "To be honest with you, I thought the police had probably sent him, and he was probably wired or something. I didn't know, you know, so I wired-up." -Question Reneer’s motivation for the ‘why’, he recorded this, he is potentially being deceptive about his underlying motivation, as he uses the phrase ‘to be honest with you’, why would he need to preface his statement with ‘to be honest’, he is potentially worried about how he will perceived and is trying to convince -The use of ‘probably’ makes me question if he truly believes the police had sent Dewayne Bell, this is further underscored where he takes it a step further and says ‘he was probably wired or something’ this is a very wishy washy statement, if he truly believed that Dewayne was wired, he wouldn’t use such a soft tone ‘probably wired up or something’ -Reneer then goes on to say ‘I didn’t know, you know, so I wired up’ Dewayne may not have known if Dewayne was wired but the language used suggests there is a low probability that he truly believed that, his use of ‘you know’ has the intent of convincing the interviewer -It’s unclear exactly what Reneer is being deceptive about, the initial part of the statement suggests his underlying motive and the latter parts suggest that he potentially did not believe that Dewayne would have been wired and is using that as an excuse or justification for why he chose to proceed with the recording. I also question, if Reneer believed the police had sent Dewayne to record him, was he potentially worried that they would find something, even if it was something completely irrelevant to Shannon Green’s disappearance John Reneer on how police handled the investigation at the time "No one set out to find what happened to Shannon. They set out to find what I did to Shannon. There's a big difference." -The first major red flag I want to highlight here which is unsettling is ‘they set out to find what I did to Shannon’ it should be ‘what they thought I did to Shannon’ this very well could be a leaked confession, again it doesn’t mean that Reneer killed her or made her disappear but there are other options of what he may have done that could be causing this type of statement -Ok, so back to the beginning of the statement, he doesn’t say specifically law enforcement, which is strange, typically when expressing frustration about police not doing an adequate job of investigating, the subject would say ‘police’ not ‘no one’ -‘Set out’ is an odd phrase and he uses it twice, does he believe she left? Sometimes a phrase like ‘set out’ means left or went somewhere, was Reneer aware Shannon went somewhere preceding her disappearance? Did they ‘set out’ somewhere together? These are fair questions to ask based on what could be a leaked confession and the odd use of ‘set out’ -The final point I want to address is that Shannon is missing, the police had theorized she ran away because of the phone call that they received and Reneer is saying ‘what happened to Shannon’ this in and of itself wouldn’t necessarily be cause for pause for me but when coupled with the rest of these few sentences, it makes me question if Reneer has more knowledge of what ‘happened’ to Shannon than he is letting on The recorded conversation (tape) John Reneer: "What's going on?" -What we can’t know is when Reneer turned on the recording device, we would think that at some point he would acknowledge Dewayne by name, especially since his objective was to record him, so for the listener it starts abruptly with ‘what’s going on’, we don’t know what led up to this point and for how long they spoke before Reneer his record -When one doesn’t feel the need to say the first name, it could speak to a sense of familiarity, for example, when I see my sister, I don’t say ‘Hi Shanelle’, I likely wouldn’t use her name, if it was a loose acquaintance, I would likely say their name in an acknowledgement that I knew who they were Dewayne Bell: "Aw, nothing. Got any money I can borrow?" -Here Dewayne answers in a strange manner if we are to believe he needs to go on the run after killing Shannon, he says ‘Aw, Nothing’, the ‘aw’ before he says nothing is a way to draw out speech while one thinks of an appropriate answer. If he would have simply answered ‘nothing’ and said nothing else, I would have believed his statement was truthful, ...
    Show More Show Less
    1 hr and 9 mins
  • Shannon Green: Dewayne Bell/John Reneer Statement Analysis Pt. One
    Nov 5 2026
    Support the show: Patreon.com/julesandashleyPatreon.com/thetrailwentcoldBelow is the transcript with my notes in case you would like to follow along: Transcript of Quotes – 14 NEWS Investigation Source material: 14 NEWS (WFIE) article screenshots. All quoted wording preserved exactly as it appeared. Non-quote narrative text omitted. Ordered as closely as possible to the chronological sequence of events. John Reneer on why he recorded the conversation (two days after Shannon Green’s disappearance) "To be honest with you, I thought the police had probably sent him, and he was probably wired or something. I didn't know, you know, so I wired-up." -Question Reneer’s motivation for the ‘why’, he recorded this, he is potentially being deceptive about his underlying motivation, as he uses the phrase ‘to be honest with you’, why would he need to preface his statement with ‘to be honest’, he is potentially worried about how he will perceived and is trying to convince -The use of ‘probably’ makes me question if he truly believes the police had sent Dewayne Bell, this is further underscored where he takes it a step further and says ‘he was probably wired or something’ this is a very wishy washy statement, if he truly believed that Dewayne was wired, he wouldn’t use such a soft tone ‘probably wired up or something’ -Reneer then goes on to say ‘I didn’t know, you know, so I wired up’ Dewayne may not have known if Dewayne was wired but the language used suggests there is a low probability that he truly believed that, his use of ‘you know’ has the intent of convincing the interviewer -It’s unclear exactly what Reneer is being deceptive about, the initial part of the statement suggests his underlying motive and the latter parts suggest that he potentially did not believe that Dewayne would have been wired and is using that as an excuse or justification for why he chose to proceed with the recording. I also question, if Reneer believed the police had sent Dewayne to record him, was he potentially worried that they would find something, even if it was something completely irrelevant to Shannon Green’s disappearance John Reneer on how police handled the investigation at the time "No one set out to find what happened to Shannon. They set out to find what I did to Shannon. There's a big difference." -The first major red flag I want to highlight here which is unsettling is ‘they set out to find what I did to Shannon’ it should be ‘what they thought I did to Shannon’ this very well could be a leaked confession, again it doesn’t mean that Reneer killed her or made her disappear but there are other options of what he may have done that could be causing this type of statement -Ok, so back to the beginning of the statement, he doesn’t say specifically law enforcement, which is strange, typically when expressing frustration about police not doing an adequate job of investigating, the subject would say ‘police’ not ‘no one’ -‘Set out’ is an odd phrase and he uses it twice, does he believe she left? Sometimes a phrase like ‘set out’ means left or went somewhere, was Reneer aware Shannon went somewhere preceding her disappearance? Did they ‘set out’ somewhere together? These are fair questions to ask based on what could be a leaked confession and the odd use of ‘set out’ -The final point I want to address is that Shannon is missing, the police had theorized she ran away because of the phone call that they received and Reneer is saying ‘what happened to Shannon’ this in and of itself wouldn’t necessarily be cause for pause for me but when coupled with the rest of these few sentences, it makes me question if Reneer has more knowledge of what ‘happened’ to Shannon than he is letting on The recorded conversation (tape) John Reneer: "What's going on?" -What we can’t know is when Reneer turned on the recording device, we would think that at some point he would acknowledge Dewayne by name, especially since his objective was to record him, so for the listener it starts abruptly with ‘what’s going on’, we don’t know what led up to this point and for how long they spoke before Reneer his record -When one doesn’t feel the need to say the first name, it could speak to a sense of familiarity, for example, when I see my sister, I don’t say ‘Hi Shanelle’, I likely wouldn’t use her name, if it was a loose acquaintance, I would likely say their name in an acknowledgement that I knew who they were Dewayne Bell: "Aw, nothing. Got any money I can borrow?" -Here Dewayne answers in a strange manner if we are to believe he needs to go on the run after killing Shannon, he says ‘Aw, Nothing’, the ‘aw’ before he says nothing is a way to draw out speech while one thinks of an appropriate answer. If he would have simply answered ‘nothing’ and said nothing else, I would have believed his statement was truthful, ...
    Show More Show Less
    53 mins
  • Teresita Basa Pt. Two
    Oct 29 2026
    Teresita Basa had immigrated to the United States from the Phillipines and was working as a respiratory therapist at Chicago's Edgewater Hospital. She was murdered on February 21st, 1997, in her Lincoln Park Apartment. She was found naked under a vburning mattress with a butcher knife in her chest after neighbors reported smoke. The Path Went Chilly until months later when coworker Remy Chua, who also hailed from the Philipines, claimed to have been possessed by Basa's spirit in a trance, speaking Tagalog and naming a fellow hospital worker as the murderer. Join us as we go through this bizarre case and see if at the end, you believe in ghosts.

    Support the Show:

    Patreon.com/julesandashley

    Patreon.com/thetrailwentcold
    Show More Show Less
    41 mins
adbl_web_anon_alc_button_suppression_t1
No reviews yet