The Psychological Eval

Hey! I'd love to hear your thoughts, send me a voice note.

In Episode 2 of The Psychological Eval, Corey examines the public commentary of social media personality and podcaster Big Matt (Matthew Chappell) through a psychological lens.

Rather than deciding who's “good” or “bad,” this episode digs into the psychology behind the way we communicate online. Using Big Matt's publicly available commentary as the starting point, Corey explores confirmation bias, social identity theory, group polarization, selective empathy, moral exclusion, and the powerful role outrage plays in social-media engagement.

But this isn't a takedown.

The evaluation also examines moments where Big Matt has advocated for people facing discrimination, creating a more complicated picture than either supporters or critics might expect. The larger question becomes whether legitimate anger toward injustice can sometimes evolve into the same kind of generalization we're trying to fight.

Hey! I'd love to hear your thoughts, send me a voice note.

Everyone has a side. But what happens when defending yours turns into tearing someone else down?

Screenshots, divided loyalties, and public insults—when does online drama become personal?

In the premiere of The Psychological Eval, Corey examines the situation involving Alana, Madison, and messages connected to Kayla’s account. Through selected posts, message excerpts, and a participant’s perspective, this episode explores how an argument about behavior becomes a battle over character and reputation.

We’re talking about public shaming, mental-health stigma, the assumptions we make about emotional reactions, and whether protecting a friend can affect how we interpret a conflict. Can compassion and accountability coexist? And what does hearing “both sides” actually require?