• Episode 118: S6E8 “All Dogs Go To Heaven”
    Nov 17 2026

    In this episode Joy and Laura break down season 6 episode 8 of Supernatural “All Dogs Go To Heaven”. Sam and Dean investigate a town where a series of fatal animal attacks have happened, that they initially think is werewolves.


    We just can’t with this episode!


    We discuss how much we hated this episode, why does not having a soul mean Sam can’t sleep? Why do they decide to kill so many dogs? Why are Sam and Dean not acting like Sam and Dean? Why is the skinwalker lore so inaccurate?


    We also discuss how this episode turns into a really bad mafia movie and demand justice for the “uncredited dog actor”.


    Joy’s Easter egg is what native Americans actually say about skinwalkers.


    Stay safe out there, have each other’s backs, and always keep fighting!


    Sources used:

    https://epguides.com/Supernatural/ (for dates of episodes)

    https://www.imdb.com/title/tt1627726/?ref_=ttep_ep_8

    https://supernaturalwiki.com/6.08_All_Dogs_Go_to_Heaven_(Transcript)

    Joy’s show notes

    Email us: thewitchesofletters@gmail.com


    Subscribe and follow us on socials:

    Find us on Instagram

    Find us on Threads

    Support the show by leaving a review and a 5 star rating wherever you listen, and sharing the episode with a friend.


    Theme music is Hard Rock (Fireman) by AlexGrohl from Pixabay



    Supernatural podcast, Supernatural TV show rewatch, Supernatural episode recap, Supernatural rewatch podcast, Supernatural fan podcast, Supernatural analysis podcast, Sam and Dean Winchester, Castiel, hunters and monsters, Supernatural demons, Supernatural angels, lore, favourite Supernatural moments, Supernatural character analysis, SPNFamily, behind the scenes Supernatural, monster of the week podcast, fun facts, paranormal, urban legends, horror, fantasy, Supernatural season 6 recap, comedy podcast, women podcasters.

    Show More Show Less
    1 hr and 28 mins
  • Episode 117: S6E7 “Family Matters”
    Nov 10 2026

    In this episode Joy and Laura break down season 6 episode 7 of Supernatural “Family Matters”. On the hunt for Sam’s soul, Sam and Dean go to Samuel to see if he remembers anything about when he and Sam were brought back from Hell, but get caught up in the hunters latest mission which is to catch the alpha vampire and torture him for information.


    We discuss the charming Alpha Vampire, everything Soulless Sam, and the ongoing conflict between Sam and Dean.


    We also discuss Samuel’s shady antics and how they all now work for Crowley.


    Stay safe out there, have each other’s backs, and always keep fighting!


    Sources used:

    https://epguides.com/Supernatural/ (for dates of episodes)

    https://www.imdb.com/title/tt1627725/?ref_=ttep_ep_7

    https://supernaturalwiki.com/6.07_Family_Matters_(Transcript)

    Email us: thewitchesofletters@gmail.com


    Subscribe and follow us on socials:

    Find us on Instagram

    Find us on Threads

    Support the show by leaving a review and a 5 star rating wherever you listen, and sharing the episode with a friend.


    Theme music is Hard Rock (Fireman) by AlexGrohl from Pixabay



    Supernatural podcast, Supernatural TV show rewatch, Supernatural episode recap, Supernatural rewatch podcast, Supernatural fan podcast, Supernatural analysis podcast, Sam and Dean Winchester, Castiel, hunters and monsters, Supernatural demons, Supernatural angels, lore, favourite Supernatural moments, Supernatural character analysis, SPNFamily, behind the scenes Supernatural, monster of the week podcast, fun facts, paranormal, urban legends, horror, fantasy, Supernatural season 6 recap, comedy podcast, women podcasters.

    Show More Show Less
    1 hr and 8 mins
  • Episode 116: S6E6 “You Can’t Handle The Truth”
    Nov 3 2026

    In this episode Joy and Laura break down season 6 episode 6 of Supernatural “You Can’t Handle The Truth”. Sam and Dean investigate a town cursed by Veritas, the goddess of truth, and we finally find out what’s up with Sam!


    We discuss Laura’s reaction to Soulless Sam, Joy’s doppelganger, and Laura blows Joy’s mind with a fun fact.


    We also discuss Dean’s attitude this season around what is happening to Sam and why, and why Sam is immune to the truth curse.


    Joy’s Easter egg is about Veritas the Goddess of Truth, and how the lore matches up to what is depicted in this episode.


    Stay safe out there, have each other’s backs, and always keep fighting!


    Sources used:

    https://epguides.com/Supernatural/ (for dates of episodes)

    https://www.imdb.com/title/tt1627723/?ref_=ttep_ep_6

    https://supernaturalwiki.com/6.06_You_Can%27t_Handle_the_Truth_(Transcript)

    Joy’s show notes

    Email us: thewitchesofletters@gmail.com


    Subscribe and follow us on socials:

    Find us on Instagram

    Find us on Threads

    Support the show by leaving a review and a 5 star rating wherever you listen, and sharing the episode with a friend.


    Theme music is Hard Rock (Fireman) by AlexGrohl from Pixabay



    Supernatural podcast, Supernatural TV show rewatch, Supernatural episode recap, Supernatural rewatch podcast, Supernatural fan podcast, Supernatural analysis podcast, Sam and Dean Winchester, Castiel, hunters and monsters, Supernatural demons, Supernatural angels, lore, favourite Supernatural moments, Supernatural character analysis, SPNFamily, behind the scenes Supernatural, monster of the week podcast, fun facts, paranormal, urban legends, horror, fantasy, Supernatural season 6 recap, comedy podcast, women podcasters.

    Show More Show Less
    1 hr and 26 mins
  • Bonus episode: Halloween 2026
    Oct 31 2026

    Happy Spooky Season! Welcome to our Halloween 2026 special bonus episode. Will Joy get us haunted this year? Listen to find out.


    In this episode Joy and Laura cover:

    • The origins of Dracula (real Vampire stories!)

    • The Third Man Syndrome

    • The Dismal Swamp Monster

    • A listener’s guardian angel story

    • A ghostly voice that led to a man’s rescue


    Stay safe out there, have each other’s backs, and always keep fighting!


    Sources used:

    Joy’s

    • Joy’s show notes

    Laura’s

    • https://www.buzzfeed.com/angelicaamartinez/third-man-syndrome

    • https://allthatsinteresting.com/third-man-syndrome

    • https://youtu.be/ecWzWRbAd40?si=Cpc57yVml9XVeKUy&t=418

    • https://www.reddit.com/r/AskReddit/s/m7gNHHWqEO

    Email us: thewitchesofletters@gmail.com


    Subscribe and follow us on socials:

    Find us on Instagram

    Find us on Threads

    Support the show by leaving a review and a 5 star rating wherever you listen, and sharing the episode with a friend.


    Theme music is Hard Rock (Fireman) by AlexGrohl from Pixabay



    Supernatural podcast, Supernatural TV show rewatch, Supernatural episode recap, Supernatural rewatch podcast, Supernatural fan podcast, Supernatural analysis podcast, Sam and Dean Winchester, Castiel, hunters and monsters, Supernatural demons, Supernatural angels, lore, favourite Supernatural moments, SPNFamily, behind the scenes Supernatural, monster of the week podcast, paranormal, urban legends, horror, fantasy, women podcasters.

    Show More Show Less
    1 hr and 20 mins
  • Episode 115: S6E5 “Live Free or Twihard”
    Oct 27 2026

    In this episode Joy and Laura break down season 6 episode 5 of Supernatural “Live Free or Twihard”, where Dean is turned into a vampire during an investigation!


    We discuss 2000’s fashion, Joy’s love for vampire Dean, and all the Twilight references.


    Stay safe out there, have each other’s backs, and always keep fighting!


    Sources used:

    https://epguides.com/Supernatural/ (for dates of episodes)

    https://www.imdb.com/title/tt1627724/?ref_=ttep_ep_5

    https://supernaturalwiki.com/6.05_Live_Free_or_Twihard_(Transcript)

    Joy’s show notes

    Email us: thewitchesofletters@gmail.com


    Subscribe and follow us on socials:

    Find us on Instagram

    Find us on Threads

    Support the show by leaving a review and a 5 star rating wherever you listen, and sharing the episode with a friend.


    Theme music is Hard Rock (Fireman) by AlexGrohl from Pixabay



    Supernatural podcast, Supernatural TV show rewatch, Supernatural episode recap, Supernatural rewatch podcast, Supernatural fan podcast, Supernatural analysis podcast, Sam and Dean Winchester, Castiel, hunters and monsters, Supernatural demons, Supernatural angels, lore, favourite Supernatural moments, Supernatural character analysis, SPNFamily, behind the scenes Supernatural, monster of the week podcast, fun facts, paranormal, urban legends, horror, fantasy, Supernatural season 6 recap, comedy podcast, women podcasters.

    Show More Show Less
    1 hr and 21 mins
  • Episode 114: S6E4 “Weekend At Bobby’s” (with Kara from Prophecy Girls)
    Oct 20 2026

    In this episode Joy and Laura break down season 6 episode 4 of Supernatural “Weekend At Bobby’s” with a recurring guest Kara from the Buffy rewatch podcast Prophecy Girls. This episode follows Bobby instead of the Winchesters as he goes about his life as a hunter.


    We discuss our love of Supernatural filler episodes, what Bobby gets up to on a daily basis, how underappreciated he is, and how Crowley has become the King of Hell!


    We also discuss Bobby’s multiple phone set up for helping the other hunters, Bobby and Rufus’ grumpy old men vibe, and how Bobby is the hero of heroes.


    Joy’s Easter eggs are about Clan McLeod (Crowley’s real name), the Lamia from Ancient Greek mythology, and the Okami from Japanese folklore.


    If you have any ghost stories to send in for our Halloween bonus episode please do, the email is a little further down in the show notes.


    Stay safe out there, have each other’s backs, and always keep fighting!


    Sources used:

    https://epguides.com/Supernatural/ (for dates of episodes)

    https://www.imdb.com/title/tt1627722/?ref_=ttep_ep_4

    https://supernaturalwiki.com/6.04_Weekend_at_Bobby%27s_(Transcript)

    Joy’s show notes

    Email us: thewitchesofletters@gmail.com

    Subscribe and follow us on socials:

    Find us on Instagram

    Find us on Threads

    Support the show by leaving a review and a 5 star rating wherever you listen, and sharing the episode with a friend.


    You can find Prophecy girls here:

    Spotify link to Prophecy Girls

    Prophecy Girls Instagram page

    Prophecy Girls website


    Theme music is Hard Rock (Fireman) by AlexGrohl from Pixabay


    Supernatural podcast, Supernatural TV show rewatch, Supernatural episode recap, Supernatural rewatch podcast, Supernatural fan podcast, Supernatural analysis podcast, Sam and Dean Winchester, Castiel, hunters and monsters, Supernatural demons, Supernatural angels, lore, favourite Supernatural moments, Supernatural character analysis, SPNFamily, behind the scenes Supernatural, monster of the week podcast, fun facts, paranormal, urban legends, horror, fantasy, Supernatural season 6 recap, comedy podcast, women podcasters.

    Show More Show Less
    1 hr and 45 mins
  • Episode 113: S6E3 “The Third Man”
    Oct 13 2026

    In this episode Joy and Laura break down season 6 episode 3 of Supernatural “The Third Man”.


    We discuss Laura’s reaction to Sam this season so far, her theory about what is going on with him, and also the Sam work out / thirst trap scene from the start.


    We also discuss Cas’ hilarious use of airquotes, how his voice seems even lower this season, Balthazar and how he might just be the Trickster 2.0, and we do evil ASMR at each other.


    Joy’s Easter eggs are about police violence in Pennsylvania.


    If you have any ghost stories to send in for our Halloween bonus episode please do, the email is a little further down in the show notes.


    Stay safe out there, have each other’s backs, and always keep fighting!


    Sources used:

    https://epguides.com/Supernatural/ (for dates of episodes)

    https://www.imdb.com/title/tt1627721/?ref_=ttep_ep_3

    https://supernaturalwiki.com/6.03_The_Third_Man_(Transcript)

    Joy’s show notes

    Email us: thewitchesofletters@gmail.com


    Subscribe and follow us on socials:

    Find us on Instagram

    Find us on Threads

    Support the show by leaving a review and a 5 star rating wherever you listen, and sharing the episode with a friend.


    Theme music is Hard Rock (Fireman) by AlexGrohl from Pixabay



    Supernatural podcast, Supernatural TV show rewatch, Supernatural episode recap, Supernatural rewatch podcast, Supernatural fan podcast, Supernatural analysis podcast, Sam and Dean Winchester, Castiel, hunters and monsters, Supernatural demons, Supernatural angels, lore, favourite Supernatural moments, Supernatural character analysis, SPNFamily, behind the scenes Supernatural, monster of the week podcast, fun facts, paranormal, urban legends, horror, fantasy, Supernatural season 5 recap, comedy podcast, women podcasters.

    Show More Show Less
    1 hr and 19 mins
  • Episode 112: S6E2 “Two and a Half Men”
    Oct 6 2026

    In this episode Joy and Laura break down season 6 episode 2 of Supernatural “Two and a Half Men”. Sam and Dean find themselves in charge of a baby boy when Sam rescues him from a crime scene where both of his parents were killed. They soon realise, however, that a shapeshifter is following them and wants the baby.


    We discuss how Dean is torn between being a hunter again and protecting his family, Dean being “father material”, shapeshifter goo, and what we think would have been a better name for this episode.


    We also stick up for all the parents out there who get made to feel bad for their baby crying in public, and Laura has a first time watcher theory about what Samuel and the hunters are up to.


    Joy’s Easter eggs are about the location of Lansing, Michigan and all of its unsolved cases and urban legends; and links this episode has to various legends, mythology and religious scripture.


    Stay safe out there, have each other’s backs, and always keep fighting!


    Sources used:

    https://epguides.com/Supernatural/ (for dates of episodes)

    https://www.imdb.com/title/tt1627717/?ref_=ttep_ep_2

    https://supernaturalwiki.com/6.02_Two_and_a_Half_Men_(Transcript)

    Joy’s show notes

    Email us: thewitchesofletters@gmail.com


    Subscribe and follow us on socials:

    Find us on Instagram

    Find us on Threads

    Support the show by leaving a review and a 5 star rating wherever you listen, and sharing the episode with a friend.


    Theme music is Hard Rock (Fireman) by AlexGrohl from Pixabay



    Supernatural podcast, Supernatural TV show rewatch, Supernatural episode recap, Supernatural rewatch podcast, Supernatural fan podcast, Supernatural analysis podcast, Sam and Dean Winchester, Castiel, hunters and monsters, Supernatural demons, Supernatural angels, lore, favourite Supernatural moments, Supernatural character analysis, SPNFamily, behind the scenes Supernatural, monster of the week podcast, fun facts, paranormal, urban legends, horror, fantasy, Supernatural season 5 recap, comedy podcast, women podcasters.

    Show More Show Less
    1 hr and 32 mins