• Season 5, Episode 12: Jim Moehring's Quest for the Holy Grail: Baseball Memories, Cincinnati Development & Reds Favorites
    May 19 2026

    Send us Fan Mail

    In this lively episode, Jim Moehring shares stories about his deep-rooted Cincinnati baseball fandom, his journey in establishing Holy Grail, and his affectionate ties to Reds legends and memories. Whether you're a Reds enthusiast or a local history buff, Jim's insights bring the Cincinnati baseball scene to life.

    Jim's insights reflect a true Cincinnati sports icon's perspective—passionate, humorous, and dedicated to community. His stories of legendary moments and local development showcase the vibrant spirit of Cincinnati baseball and downtown life.

    Key Topics Covered:

    • Jim’s earliest memories of Cincinnati Reds and fan experiences as a kid gazing at dry cleaner windows displaying jerseys;
    • His childhood baseball teams, favorite players like Johnny Bench, and the significance of memorabilia;
    • Behind-the-scenes stories of how Johnny Bench personally signed a plaque at Holy Grail;
    • The origins of Holy Grail, how Jim seized the name and built a local sports bar brand;
    • Playing a role in the development of Downtown Cincinnati, including insights on the banks area and its evolution
    • Memorable moments, including the 2015 All-Star Game and legendary Reds games like Billy Bates’ game-winning hit
    • Insights on Reds management decisions, rivals like the Cubs and Cardinals, and players he admires
    • His ideal Reds roster, including players he'd love to see in a Reds uniform today
    • The importance of supporting local independent businesses in Cincinnati;
    • Jim’s legendary restaurant stories, including rushes on opening days and the crazy pace of starting Holy Grail during the Reds' Opening Day;
    • Favorite baseball movies, such as Sandlot, and top moments like the 1990 World Series;
    • The most amazing game moments Jim has witnessed firsthand, including Hernandez’s walk-off homer;
    • His pick for the clutch player to bat in the bottom of the ninth and his chosen Reds pitcher for high-stakes situations;
    • Nostalgic favorites, including Reds from the '90s and legendary figures like Pete Rose and Johnny Bench;
    • Jim’s dream dinner guests, including Reds legends and team staff; and
    • Fun anecdotes involving Reds personalities and local Cincinnati hotspots.

    Timestamps:

    00:00 - Introduction to Jim Moehring and his Cincinnati baseball roots
    02:30 - Jim’s childhood teams and favorite players
    04:36 - Johnny Bench tales and memorabilia behind Holy Grail
    08:05 - How Holy Grail was established and Cincinnati restaurant scene
    09:39 - Holy Grail's early days and downtown development insights
    13:21 - Opening Holy Grail during Reds home opener rushes
    15:46 - Local support and the importance of independent businesses
    19:55 - Ideas for downtown Cincinnati enhancements and arena prospects
    23:16 - Stories of Reds' management decisions and rivalries
    27:26 - Reds players who made the Mount Rushmore in Jim’s eyes
    28:12 - Dream Reds lineup for a dinner party
    32:45 - Clutch moments and legendary game highlights
    36:06 - Reds players and legends Jim admires most
    40:12 - Most memorable Reds game moments witnessed
    42:07 - Closing remarks and future hopes for Reds and Cincinnati

    Connect with Jim Moehring:

    • Holy Grail Cincinnati Facebook
    • Holy Grail Instagram


    Jack thanks the listeners

    Show More Show Less
    44 mins
  • Season 5, Episode 11: Justin McGuire and "Baseball By The Book"
    May 12 2026

    Send us Fan Mail

    In this engaging episode of "We Love Our Team," hosts Jack Greiner and Randy Freking welcome Justin McGuire, a seasoned journalist and host of the podcast "Baseball by the Book." The conversation delves into Justin's early baseball fandom, his favorite players, and his career journey, including his time as a baseball editor for the Sporting News. Justin shares insights into his podcast, which focuses on baseball literature, and discusses memorable baseball moments and figures. The episode is filled with nostalgic reflections on baseball history, personal anecdotes, and lively discussions about the sport's cultural impact.

    This summary captures the essence of the episode by highlighting the personal stories and historical insights shared, appealing to both baseball enthusiasts and those interested in storytelling.

    Top Insights

    1. The evolution of baseball leadership reflects broader cultural shifts.
    2. Baseball history demonstrates the importance of social context over time.
    3. The changing face of baseball strategies reflects a broader realignment of mental models.
    4. The craft of sports storytelling preserves cultural memory and shapes values.
    5. Emotional connections to iconic moments reveal the power of personal memory in shaping perception.
    6. The enduring relevance of classical aesthetics speaks to the principle of design simplicity.
    7. Diving into systemic issues through storytelling reveals how narratives shape societal change.


    Chapters

    • Introduction and Justin’s baseball fandom origins
    • Early Orioles memories and favorite players
    • Playing Little League and managing skills
    • Legendary managers like Earl Weaver and baseball personality changes
    • Justin’s career in baseball journalism and podcast journey
    • The enduring appeal of baseball literature and notable books
    • History of black players before Jackie Robinson
    • A compelling story from the 1955 Charleston Little League team
    • The Yankees late 70s dominance and disliked players
    • Baseball Mount Rushmore: Ruth, Robinson, Rickey, and Mays
    • The significance of Marvin Miller in baseball history
    • Fun topics: favorite uniforms, ballpark foods, and memorable moments
    • Favorite baseball movies like The Bad News Bears and Bull Durham
    • Justin’s ideal walk-up song and baseball traditions
    • Classic uniforms and personal favorites
    • Most memorable visits to the ballpark and game moments
    • Nicest player met in person: Rod Carew
    • Justin’s thoughts on Pete Rose and gambling in baseball
    • Future baseball stadium visits and closing remarks


    Jack thanks the listeners

    Show More Show Less
    46 mins
  • Season 5, Episode 10: Brendon Cull, President and CEO of Cincinnati Regional Chamber
    May 5 2026

    Send us Fan Mail

    Join us as we explore Brendon Cull's journey from baseball fandom to leading the Cincinnati Regional Chamber. Discover insights on Cincinnati's community, sports culture, and economic development, all through Brendan’s engaging stories and expertise.

    Key Topics

    Brendon Cull's baseball memories and fandom

    • Impact of professional sports on Cincinnati's economy
    • Cincinnati's community development and growth
    • Historical insights into Cincinnati's sports venues and teams
    • Leadership and initiatives of the Cincinnati Chamber

    Sound Bites

    • "I came to Cincinnati for Xavier University."
    • "I despise the St. Louis Cardinals."
    • "Johnny Gomes for a bench clearing brawl."

    Chapters

    00:00
    Introduction to Brendon Cull and His Baseball Journey

    02:50
    Transitioning from Dodgers to Reds Fandom

    05:30
    Brendan's Connection to Cincinnati and Xavier University

    10:56
    The Role of the Cincinnati Chamber of Commerce

    16:01
    The Economic Impact of the Reds on Cincinnati

    21:23
    Cincinnati's Renaissance and Community Growth

    23:37
    Fan Perspectives and Rivalries in Baseball

    27:14
    Dinner Party with Reds Greats

    30:06
    Memorable Reds Moments

    33:34
    Must-Read Baseball Books

    36:02
    Best Reds Pitchers for Clutch Situations

    36:40
    Favorite Baseball Movies

    38:06
    Walk-Up Songs and Music Influence

    39:04
    Favorite Reds Uniforms

    39:43
    Unforgettable Game Experiences

    40:26
    Meeting Reds Legends

    41:44
    Choosing a Fighter for a Brawl

    42:40
    Speed Demons on the Basepaths

    43:19
    Best Hair in Reds History

    44:11
    Cincinnati's Rich History and Future

    Jack thanks the listeners

    Show More Show Less
    46 mins
  • Season 5, Episode 9: David Pepper, Mr. Cincinnati
    Apr 28 2026

    Send us Fan Mail

    Jack Greiner and Randy Freking welcome David Pepper, a lifelong Cincinnatian and former chairman of the Ohio Democratic Party. The conversation covers David's deep-rooted passion for the Cincinnati Reds, sharing nostalgic memories and discussing favorite players like Eric Davis and Ken Griffey Jr. David also talks about his political journey, his books on gerrymandering, and his candidacy for lieutenant governor alongside Amy Acton. The episode is filled with engaging anecdotes, baseball trivia, and a shared love for Cincinnati sports.

    Keywords:

    • Cincinnati Reds
    • David Pepper
    • Eric Davis
    • Ken Griffey Jr.
    • Ohio Democratic Party
    • Gerrymandering
    • Amy Acton
    • Baseball nostalgia
    • Cincinnati sports
    • Political journey

    Chapters:

    1. Introduction and Guest Welcome (0:00 - 0:42)

      • Hosts introduce David Pepper and his background.
    2. Reds Fandom and Early Memories (0:42 - 2:39)

      • David shares his early experiences as a Reds fan.
    3. Favorite Players and Baseball Stories (2:39 - 5:40)

      • Discussion about favorite players like Eric Davis and Ken Griffey Jr.
    4. Political Career and Writing (5:40 - 14:18)

      • David talks about his political journey and his books.
    5. Running for Lieutenant Governor (14:18 - 17:09)

      • Insights into David's candidacy with Amy Acton.
    6. Baseball and Politics (17:09 - 22:32)

      • The intersection of sports fandom and political life.
    7. Fun Categories and Personal Stories (22:32 - 42:54)

      • Engaging segments like "Marty McFly" and "Mount Rushmore" of Reds players.
    8. Conclusion and Optimism for the Season (42:54 - End)

      • Closing thoughts and excitement for the upcoming baseball season.

    Jack thanks the listeners

    Show More Show Less
    44 mins
  • Season 5, Episode 8: Gary Schatz, a Character of the Game and Statistician
    Apr 21 2026

    Send us Fan Mail

    This episode is sponsored by LeRosa's Pizzeria! Listen and Win.

    Join us as we chat with Gary Schatz, son of Dick Schatz, a dedicated Reds fan and baseball statistician since 1992. Discover his insights on Reds history, memorable moments, and his unique perspective on the game.

    Key Topics

    • Gary Schatz's baseball fandom origins
    • Favorite Reds players and managers
    • Memorable Reds games and moments
    • Insights on Reds history and players
    • Personal stories and anecdotes

    Sound Bites

    • "Vada Pinson belongs in the Hall of Fame"
    • "Tony Perez is the ultimate clutch hitter"

    Jack thanks the listeners

    Show More Show Less
    44 mins
  • Season 5, Episode 7: David Shannon and The Unmarked Graves Project; Preserving Reds History
    Apr 14 2026

    Send us Fan Mail

    Join David Shannon as we explore the fascinating world of Reds fandom, historic moments, and a unique project dedicated to unmarked graves of former Reds players. Discover stories, insights, and the passion behind preserving baseball history.

    Key Topics

    • Reds fandom and early memories
    • The Unmarked Graves Project and its mission
    • Historical Reds players and their stories
    • The process of researching and installing gravesites
    • Memorable Reds moments and players

    Sound Bites

    • "Really good tickets probably cost $10 or $15"
    • "Mario Soto was my favorite Reds player"
    • "Hank Gastrite pitched a no-hitter in 1924"

    Chapters

    00:00
    Introduction to David Shannon and His Project

    13:32
    The Unmarked Graves Project: Mission and Impact

    31:12
    Reconnecting Through History

    34:46
    Fundraising for Forgotten Players

    37:22
    Upcoming Projects and Community Engagement

    42:33
    Reflecting on Reds History

    46:08
    Dinner Party with Reds Legends

    48:09
    Dreaming of Future Reds

    48:42
    Ballpark Favorites and Memorable Moments

    51:06
    Baseball Movies and Clichés

    52:49
    Favorite Reds Uniforms



    Jack thanks the listeners

    Show More Show Less
    56 mins
  • Season 5, Episode 6: Rick Redman, Louisville Slugger Museum Secrets!
    Apr 7 2026

    Send us Fan Mail

    Summary

    Join us as Rick Redman, Vice President of Louisville Slugger Museum and Factory, shares his lifelong passion for baseball, insights into the iconic brand, and memorable moments from his career. Discover the rich history of Louisville Slugger, legendary players, and the cultural significance of America's pastime.

    Key Topics

    • History of Louisville Slugger
    • Memorable Baseball Moments
    • Legendary Players and Their Bats

    Sound Bites

    • "Baseball mirrors life, ups and downs, keep swinging."
    • "Louisville Slugger is an iconic name worldwide."
    • "Ozzie Smith and Eddie Murray were high school teammates."

    Chapters

    00:00
    Introduction to Rick Redman and Baseball Fandom

    10:19
    Favorite Players and Managers in Baseball

    20:17
    Journey to Louisville Slugger Museum

    30:18
    Noteworthy Prospects and Players in Louisville

    35:47
    Authenticity in Sports Conversations

    36:27
    Nostalgia for Childhood Teams

    37:29
    Rivalries and Dislike for Teams

    39:05
    The Impact of Iconic Players

    42:18
    Mount Rushmore of Reds Legends

    44:13
    Dinner Party with Baseball Legends

    50:08
    Dream Players for the Reds

    52:00
    Ballpark Food Favorites

    52:35
    Memorable Reds Moments

    54:25
    Clutch Moments in Reds History

    55:22
    Best Pitcher for Critical Situations

    56:41
    Favorite Baseball Movies

    57:54
    Walk-Up Songs for Players

    58:43
    Favorite Reds Uniforms

    59:52
    Favorite Backup Players

    Jack thanks the listeners

    Show More Show Less
    1 hr and 3 mins
  • Season 5, Episode 5: Jim Borgman, Tom Borgman, and Bob Hust; Prepare to Laugh
    Mar 31 2026

    Send us Fan Mail

    Three Elder Panthers share their stories about spring training, their younger fandom, favorite players, their choices for Reds Mount Rushmore, players/teams they dislike, and much more. Entertaining to say the least!

    Key Frameworks

    • Lifelong fandom stories
    • Spring training behind-the-scenes
    • Iconic moments in Reds history

    Action Items

    • Share your own Reds memories on social media
    • Visit spring training sites to experience the Reds culture
    • Learn more about Reds legends and history

    Sound Bites

    • "Jim Maloney was my favorite player."
    • "Pete Rose's fight in the 73 playoffs."
    • "The Johnny Bench home run story."

    Chapters

    00:00
    Introduction to Lifelong Reds Fandom

    03:19
    Early Memories of Baseball and the Reds

    06:21
    Favorite Players and Personal Connections

    09:17
    Spring Training Experiences and Connections

    12:18
    Reflections on Reds Management Decisions

    14:23
    Despicable Players and Rivalries

    24:00
    Nostalgic Baseball Memories

    24:34
    Living in the Heart of Rivalry

    27:51
    Mount Rushmore of Reds Legends

    31:42
    Memorable Ballpark Experiences

    38:00
    Dream Players in a Reds Uniform

    41:02
    Significant Moments Away from the Ballpark

    44:48
    Clutch Moments and Legendary Players

    47:53
    Baseball Legends and Favorite Players

    48:54
    The Best Baseball Movies

    51:23
    Iconic Baseball Uniforms

    53:15
    Unsung Heroes of Baseball

    55:21
    Bench Clearing Brawls and Tough Players

    57:23
    Memorable Moments in Baseball History

    Jack thanks the listeners

    Show More Show Less
    1 hr and 7 mins