Episodes

  • 97 - Three Teeth
    Feb 17 2026

    Helen and Liz discuss "Unrequited," along with orc facts, Liz's cell phone bathroom incident, and the electromagnetic phenomenon that would make Helen "expire on the spot." Plus, an insightful listener comment solves another listener's mystery—with physics!

    💚👽💚👽💚

    Find more info about Helen and Liz at our podcast website: wewanttobelievepod.com

    Follow us on Instagram: @WeWanttoBelievePod

    Email us with your questions, thoughts, or your own spooky X-files-style experiences here: wewanttobelievepod@gmail.com

    Buy Liz's young adult novel, Mighty Millie Novak, anywhere you buy books, or start here: elizabeth-holden.com/millie.html

    Show More Show Less
    47 mins
  • 96 - Clayboy
    Feb 10 2026

    Liz and Helen discuss "Kaddish," along with a sexy magazine for historic monsters, a clever goat, and a Gargoyle vs Tooms penalty shoot-out.

    💚👽💚👽💚

    Find more info about Helen and Liz at our podcast website: wewanttobelievepod.com

    Follow us on Instagram: @WeWanttoBelievePod

    Email us with your questions, thoughts, or your own spooky X-files-style stories here: wewanttobelievepod@gmail.com

    Buy Liz's young adult novel, Mighty Millie Novak, anywhere you buy books, or start here: elizabeth-holden.com/millie.html

    Show More Show Less
    1 hr
  • 95 - West Virginia Tourism Strategy
    Feb 3 2026

    Helen and Liz talk about "Memento Mori," along with Reynard the Fox, the horrors of Punch and Judy, and the latin for taking a brief break from knowing that you will die. Also, a very quick discussion of the first Round of Eight match-up in our X-Files villains bracket: Mrs. Paddock vs the Flukeman.

    💚👽💚👽💚

    Find more info about Helen and Liz at our podcast website: wewanttobelievepod.com

    Follow us on Instagram: @WeWanttoBelievePod

    Email us with your questions, thoughts, or your own spooky X-files-style stories here: wewanttobelievepod@gmail.com

    Buy Liz's young adult novel, Mighty Millie Novak, anywhere you buy books, or start here: elizabeth-holden.com/millie.html

    Show More Show Less
    51 mins
  • 94 - LeBron for a Day
    Jan 27 2026

    Liz and Helen discuss "Small Potatoes," along with general body-swapping strategy and a perhaps-controversial outcome in the Pfaster vs. van Blundht match-up.

    💚👽💚👽💚

    Find more info about Helen and Liz at our podcast website: wewanttobelievepod.com

    Follow us on Instagram: @WeWanttoBelievePod

    Email us with your questions, thoughts, or your own spooky X-files-style stories here: wewanttobelievepod@gmail.com

    Buy Liz's young adult novel, Mighty Millie Novak, anywhere you buy books, or start here: elizabeth-holden.com/millie.html

    Show More Show Less
    56 mins
  • REVIEW DAY - The Crown Prince of Russia
    Jan 6 2026

    REVIEW DAY! We're taking a few weeks off for the holidays, so today we're replaying our Season 2 episode "The Crown Prince of Russia," where we discuss the Season 2 episode "Irresistible." This is your chance to brush up on your Donnie Pfaster knowledge in advance of his battle with Eddie van Blundt in our villains tournament, which we'll be talking about in our new episode next week!

    💚👽💚👽💚

    Find more info about Helen and Liz at our podcast website: wewanttobelievepod.com

    Follow us on Instagram: @WeWanttoBelievePod

    Email us with your questions, thoughts, or your own spooky X-files-style stories here: wewanttobelievepod@gmail.com

    Buy Liz's young adult novel, Mighty Millie Novak, anywhere you buy books, or start here: elizabeth-holden.com/millie.html

    Show More Show Less
    1 hr and 8 mins
  • REVIEW DAY - Muskrat Love
    Dec 30 2025

    REVIEW DAY! We're taking a few weeks off for the holidays, so today we're replaying our Season 3 episode "Muskrat Love." We discuss the Season 3 episode "2Shy," along with bad dates, bad screen names, and bad songs. Next new episode coming January 13!

    💚👽💚👽💚

    Find more info about Helen and Liz at our podcast website: wewanttobelievepod.com

    Follow us on Instagram: @WeWanttoBelievePod

    Email us with your questions, thoughts, or your own spooky X-files-style stories here: wewanttobelievepod@gmail.com

    Buy Liz's young adult novel, Mighty Millie Novak, anywhere you buy books, or start here: elizabeth-holden.com/millie.html

    Show More Show Less
    1 hr and 14 mins
  • REVIEW DAY - Bagpipes Can Mean Anything
    Dec 23 2025

    REVIEW DAY! We're taking a few weeks off for the holidays, so today we're replaying our Season 2 episode "Bagpipes Can Mean Anything." We discuss the season 2 episode "Duane Barry," along with the first appearance of Krychek, Mulder in a speedo, and threats posed by musical instruments. Plus Helen quickly debunks Liz's "sentient liquids" theory. Next new episode coming January 13!

    💚👽💚👽💚

    Find more info about Helen and Liz at our podcast website: wewanttobelievepod.com

    Follow us on Instagram: @WeWanttoBelievePod

    Email us with your questions, thoughts, or your own spooky X-files-style stories here: wewanttobelievepod@gmail.com

    Buy Liz's young adult novel, Mighty Millie Novak, anywhere you buy books, or start here: elizabeth-holden.com/millie.html

    Show More Show Less
    1 hr and 4 mins
  • 93 - Talking Dinner Rolls
    Dec 16 2025

    Helen and Liz discuss "Never Again," along with the villain match-up of one creepy dude vs two snarky teens, plus a listener story with a possible time loop.

    💚👽💚👽💚

    Find more info about Helen and Liz at our podcast website: wewanttobelievepod.com

    Follow us on Instagram: @WeWanttoBelievePod

    Email us with your questions, thoughts, or your own spooky X-files-style stories here: wewanttobelievepod@gmail.com

    Buy Liz's young adult novel, Mighty Millie Novak, anywhere you buy books, or start here: elizabeth-holden.com/millie.html

    Show More Show Less
    47 mins