Season's Savings | ₹5/mo for 3 months

₹199/month after first 3 months. Renews automatically. Terms apply.
What Likely Happened… cover art

What Likely Happened…

What Likely Happened…

Written by: Sean
Listen for free

About this listen
Beneath the noise of sensationalized theories and unsolved mysteries lies the simplest truth. What Likely Happened... cuts through the speculation of true crime history, examining cold cases, missing persons, and historic disappearances through the unyielding lens of Occam’s razor. Join host Sean as we strip away the improbable to uncover the most logical, evidence-driven explanations behind history’s most baffling vanishing acts.Sean True Crime
Episodes
  • What Likely Happened to 12-year-old Steven Earl Kraft, Jr. /// 6
    Nov 17 2026

    Episode Description (Show Notes):

    On the freezing night of February 15, 2001, 12-year-old Steven Earl Kraft, Jr. stepped outside his Benton Township, Michigan home with his two dogs—a German Shepherd mix and a six-month-old puppy—and vanished without a trace.Days later, both dogs were found alive miles apart, while Steven’s boot prints abruptly stopped near a frozen pond behind a local church. Over the last twenty-five years, investigators have scrutinized notorious child kidnappers like Michael Devlin and Israel Keyes while combing miles of woods and creeks.On this episode of What Likely Happened, host Sean breaks down the factual timeline, examines the serial predator theories, and uses Occam’s razor to weigh law enforcement's kidnapping classification against a simple, tragic chain reaction: a six-month-old puppy bolting into the dark Michigan winter.


    Have Information?


    If you have any information regarding the disappearance of Steven Earl Kraft, Jr., please contact the Benton Township Police Department at (269) 926-8221, the FBI Detroit Field Office at (313) 965-2323, or Crime Stoppers at 1-800-342-STOP (7867).


    Sources & Further Reading:

    • FBI Detroit Field Office: Kidnappings & Missing Persons – Steven Earl Kraft, Jr. (fbi.gov/wanted/kidnap/steven-earl-kraft-jr-1)
    • Inside the FBI Podcast: Searching for Steven (August 2023)
    • WSBT 22 News: Cold Case Files: The Disappearance of Steven Kraft
    • ClickOnDetroit (WDIV): Boy last seen walking dogs in Berrien County neighborhood still missing 23 years later (February 2024)
    • The Charley Project: Steven Earl Kraft, Jr. Case File (charleyproject.org)


    #TrueCrime #ColdCase #MissingPerson #StevenEarlKraftJr #TrueCrimePodcast #UnsolvedMysteries #Michigan #WhatLikelyHappened

    Show More Show Less
    15 mins
  • What Likely Happened to 17 Year-Old -Shelbie Lynn Dwyer? /// 5
    Nov 16 2026

    On Memorial Day, May 31, 2010, 17-year-old mother Shelbie Lynn Dwyer vanished from her home in Gooding, Idaho. Her live-in boyfriend claimed she woke up at 4:00 a.m. and walked out to buy cigarettes—leaving behind her infant son, her cell phone, her purse, and her ID. Yet when police pulled surveillance video from every gas station in town, Shelbie wasn't on a single frame. In this episode of What Likely Happened, we trace the timeline, examine the domestic red flags, slice through the "4:00 a.m. walk" alibi using Occam's razor, compare it to the Kelsey Berreth no-body conviction, and evaluate where this case lands on our Solvability Scale.

    Have a tip? Contact the Gooding Police Department at (208) 934-8436 or the FBI Salt Lake City Field Office at (801) 579-1400. An FBI reward remains active.


    Episode Chapters:
    00:00 - Welcome & Cold Open
    00:55 - Setting the Stage: Gooding, Idaho & Domestic Red Flags
    03:15 - May 31, 2010: The 4:00 AM "Cigarette Run"
    05:45 - Empty Security Cameras & FBI Escalation
    08:00 - Cross-Referencing the 4 Theories
    10:15 - Applying Occam's Razor: Slicing Through the Alibi
    13:30 - Solvable vs. Will It Be Solved? & Final Verdict


    Sources & Case Records:

    • FBI Kidnappings & Missing Persons – Shelbie Lynn Dwyer: fbi.gov
    • The Charley Project – Shelbie Lynn Dwyer Case File: charleyproject.org
    • NamUs #MP7672 – Shelbie Lynn Dwyer Official Missing Person Record: ojp.gov
    • KTVB 7 (Boise, ID – Gooding Teen Mother Missing & Surveillance Camera Findings): ktvb.com
    • MagicValley.com / Times-News (Gooding Police & FBI Reward Updates): magicvalley.com
    • FBI Uniform Crime Reporting (UCR) Expanded Homicide Offender Data: cjis.gov
    Show More Show Less
    10 mins
  • Disappearance of 5 Year-Old Dulce Maria Alavez and The Man in the Red Van /// 4
    Nov 15 2026

    On September 16, 2019, 5-year-old Dulce María Alavez vanished from Bridgeton City Park in New Jersey while playing on the swings just 30 yards from her mother's car. While true stranger abductions are statistically rare, the physical timeline and independent witness accounts tell a chilling story. In this episode of What Likely Happened, we review the timestamped Sunoco surveillance video, examine the family's background and alibis, evaluate the search for the red van and composite sketches, compare this case to the Morgan Nick breakthrough, and evaluate whether this case will ever be solved.


    Have a tip? Contact the Bridgeton Police Department at (856) 451-0033 or the FBI at 1-800-CALL-FBI. A combined $75,000 reward remains active.Episode Chapters:
    00:00 - Welcome & The Stranger Abduction Exception
    01:15 - Setting the Stage: The Household & Key Players
    03:30 - September 16, 2019: What the Sunoco Video Proves
    06:15 - The Red Van, Witness Sketches & Playground Blind Spot
    08:30 - Cross-Referencing the 3 Theories
    10:45 - Applying Occam's Razor: Why This Case Breaks the Rule
    13:30 - The Morgan Nick Parallel, Solvability Scale & Final Verdict


    Sources & Case Records:

    • FBI Kidnappings & Missing Persons – Dulce María Alavez: fbi.gov
    • 6ABC Philadelphia (7-Year Anniversary & Ongoing Search Updates): 6abc.com
    • CBS Philadelphia (Father Edgar Perez Video Statement & Alibi): cbsnews.com
    • NJ.com (Surveillance Video from Sunoco Convenience Store): nj.com
    • Crime Junkie (Dulce María Alavez Case Overview & Timeline): crimejunkiepodcast.com
    • National Center for Missing & Exploited Children (NCMEC Age-Progression Profile): missingkids.org
    • Othram Labs (Morgan Nick DNA Breakthrough Overview): dnasolves.com
    • U.S. Department of Justice (NISMART Non-Family Abduction Data): ojp.gov


    Show More Show Less
    11 mins
adbl_web_anon_alc_button_suppression_t1
No reviews yet