Episodes

  • S3 Episode 4: The Prom Night Murders
    Oct 21 2026

    On a sleepy Sunday in 1989, the small town of Lakeville, Indiana was rocked to its core when one of the local pastors and his family were found by his parishioners, brutally murdered in their home. The police’s only suspect? The oldest son. The suspicion falls to him when he is seen driving his car to the Prom, even though his father had barred him from doing so. Join Owen and Billie as they outline the foundation of this infamous murder and begin to pick apart the police work on the case. The timeline? Flimsy at best. The police work? Half-assed. The pathology? Don’t get them started. With information sourced from Crime Junkie, hear all about one of rural Indiana’s biggest cases; The Prom Night Murders: The Pelley Family.


    As always: Share, Subscribe, and Follow @cuppa_tea_podcast on Instagram. More thrilling segments to come, so stay tuned!!

    Show More Show Less
    47 mins
  • S3 Episode 3: Is it me? Am I the Villain?
    Sep 16 2026

    Am I the A-Hole? Am I overreacting? Well, if you botched your own proposal and blamed it on your coworker or feel “stranded” at a restaurant for only 20 minutes, then you might be! Join Carly and Owen as they read Reddit stories and, in true Aries/Scorpio fashion, give their unabashed opinions! But everyone has opinions and viewpoints, right? That’s why we want to hear from you on all the stories. Listen to the episode and then comment on our socials or Spotify all your thoughts, concerns, questions, or out there takes!


    As always: Share, Subscribe, and Follow @cuppa_tea_podcast on Instagram. More thrilling segments to come, so stay tuned!!

    Show More Show Less
    1 hr and 34 mins
  • S3 Episode 2 Pt 2: ....pation!!!
    Aug 20 2026

    *SPOILERS*

    Put your hands on your hips and take a jump to the left as we return for Part 2 of Billie and Owen’s trip review. Join them as they dive into all things Rocky Horror Revival. From god-tier casting, to onstage sex-capades, to soul touching moments of transcendence. These two review it all! Walk with them as they paint a picture of their journey from the first steps into Studio 54 to leaving with merch they said they wouldn’t buy. Get ready for that lisp you didn’t want, opinions you didn’t ask for, and repetitions you can’t stand as we do the Time Warp again!


    As always: Share, Subscribe, and Follow @cuppa_tea_podcast on Instagram. More thrilling segments to come, so stay tuned!!


    (Addendum: The revival has been extended until February 2027 and has had several cast changes since this recording)

    Show More Show Less
    1 hr
  • S3 Episode 2 Pt 1: We See You Shiver With Antici...
    Aug 6 2026

    “We would like, if we may, to take you on a strange journey.” That journey being a trip on the Connecticut MTA with Owen and co-host Billie. Listen to their original train ride into NYC while they discuss their musical viewing habits past, present, and future.

    A follow-up Zoom call for recapping and debriefing is a necessity given the amount of wrong information and mispronunciations Owen threw out there with confidence. Zoom proves to be a worthy adversary, giving Owen an artificial lisp (we promise the audio quality will keep getting better) .

    As always: Share, Subscribe, and Follow @cuppa_tea_podcast on Instagram. Keep an eye out for Part 2; where they dive into all things Rocky! We see you shiver with antici….


    (Addendum: Cats is getting a cast album in 2026 and has shortened their run to 8/8/2026)

    Show More Show Less
    51 mins
  • S3 Episode 1: Librarian or Nuclear Physicist?
    Jul 15 2026

    Welcome Back! We are joined by our recurring co-host; Librarian, Writer, Interviewer, and Chernobyl Enthusiast, Maddy! Join her and Owen as they discuss the wonderful worlds of writing and acting. Between learning how to write and judging other's controversial writing opinions; Maddy will "red string" you through the events of nuclear reactor catastrophe. All the while, Owen is painfully unaware of how close to the mic he is (apologies... we tried to fix it in post)! Get cozy and get you creative juices flowing!

    As always: Share, Subscribe, and Follow cuppa_tea_podcast on Instagram. More thrilling segments to come, so stay tuned!!

    Show More Show Less
    1 hr and 5 mins
  • Trailer: Season 3!!!
    May 21 2026

    Don’t let an unintended 3 year hiatus fool you; we’ve missed you all!! Join our host, Owen, and his plethora of co-hosts for the same chaotic antics, sarcastic quips, and general stupidity that you know and love! This time around, we are bringing in some new voices with their own topics to shock and excite! Along with our anticipation to get the ball rolling; we welcome you all back with a brand new intro/outro and cover art as well! Get your kettles ready, dust off those mugs, and pull up a chair because You, Me, & A Cup of Tea Season 3 is finally coming! You won’t wanna miss it!

    Show More Show Less
    3 mins
  • Mini-sode 1: Bonerbo and Dunino Den
    May 2 2023
    Enjoy this first country joy ride in Scotland with Dee and Owen’s cacophony of ADHD.
    Show More Show Less
    13 mins
  • S2 Episode 4 Part 4: The Murder Rachel Veinson
    Apr 16 2023

    ****WARNING!!! Contains spoilers for Hunt A Killer Mystery Box: Dead Below Deck. ALL COPYRIGHT BELONGS TO HUNT A KILLER AND GNOMISH HAT INC.****

    Our thrilling investigation comes to a close as Billie and Owen reveal the contents inside the lockbox, stroke out while reading Morse code, decode secret captain's logs, and fill in the puzzle pieces of missing information that paint a clear picture of who murdered Rachel Veinson. Billie sounding like a creaking door combined with Owen's illiteracy with the last name Veinson provides comic relief as they travel down a wormhole of wild theories. Grab your notes from the previous episode and see if you discovered the murderer before our dutiful detective hosts.


    As always: Share, Subscribe, and Follow cuppa_tea_podcast on Instagram. More thrilling segments to come, so stay tuned!!

    Show More Show Less
    48 mins