Season's Savings | ₹5/mo for 3 months

₹199/month after first 3 months. Renews automatically. Terms apply.
Marketing Autopsy: WeWork — The Story That Outran the Business cover art

Marketing Autopsy: WeWork — The Story That Outran the Business

Marketing Autopsy: WeWork — The Story That Outran the Business

Listen for free

View show details
About this listen

In January 2019 WeWork was valued at forty-seven billion dollars. Six weeks after it filed to go public, the offering was withdrawn and the founder was gone. SoftBank stepped in at a valuation of about eight billion.

Nothing about the business changed in those six weeks. What changed is that people could finally read the numbers.

That makes this the cleanest case study in marketing we have. There was no investigative reporter, no leak, no whistleblower. The company published the document itself, voluntarily. And the market simply compared the story to the filing.

What this episode is actually about

  • Positioning is a claim about reality. WeWork leased buildings long and sublet them short — real-estate arbitrage, and a genuinely useful product. The pitch was a technology company that would elevate the world's consciousness. Technology companies get technology multiples. The gap between those two sentences was most of the forty-seven billion.
  • "Community adjusted EBITDA." A custom metric that removed not just interest, taxes, depreciation and amortisation but also marketing, general and administrative costs, and development and design. A test you can use for any custom metric: ask what it excludes, and whether the exclusions happen to be exactly the costs that make the picture look bad. The detail that should stay with you — that metric appears nowhere in the S-1. It survived precisely as long as it lived in documents nobody had to defend.
  • Why nobody said it. Plenty of people inside the company could see the lease obligations. The failure wasn't that nobody knew. It was that saying so was socially expensive — right up until it became catastrophically expensive not to have said it.
  • Your most enthusiastic investor is not validation. Agreement among people inside the story is not evidence.

And the part I don't want you to get wrong: the marketing here was excellent. The brand, the spaces, the sense of belonging — all real, all valuable. What failed was asking a story to carry weight the business model couldn't support.

So tell the biggest true story you can about your business. Then go and check what it's standing on.

If this was useful, subscribing genuinely helps the show.

Hosted by Joe Whyte of Red Wagon Agency.

adbl_web_anon_alc_button_suppression_t1
No reviews yet