What happens when we can measure more about people than ever before—but still may not understand them any better?
In this episode of Two Doctors and a Twist, Dr. Marilyn Carroll explores what her return to graduate study in clinical psychology is teaching her about one of the most important challenges of the AI era: how we decide what counts as meaningful evidence about another human being.
Drawing from her studies, emerging psychological research, and her work as a professor, executive coach, consultant, and AI governance researcher, Dr. Carroll examines the growing intersection of clinical psychology, assessment, artificial intelligence, and human judgment.
Today, clinicians and researchers can draw from psychological testing, clinical interviews, electronic health records, neuroimaging, biomarkers, wearable devices, digital behavior, treatment histories, and increasingly, AI-generated predictions. But more information does not automatically produce greater understanding.
A questionnaire is not the person.
A brain scan is not the person.
A diagnosis is not the person.
And an AI prediction is not a diagnosis.
Dr. Carroll explores why different forms of evidence can sometimes tell different stories about the same individual, why AI may perform well at recognizing psychological information yet struggle with the complexity of diagnosis, and why future clinicians may increasingly become evidence integrators—professionals responsible for determining which signals deserve weight, which measurements apply, and where technology’s conclusions require deeper human interpretation.
The goal is not humans versus machines.
It is building systems in which human judgment, clinical evidence, measurement, and technology can challenge, complement, and correct one another.
As psychology enters an era of unprecedented data, the defining question may no longer be whether we can measure the human being.
It may be whether we can still see the human being behind the measurement.
The human variable is not disappearing. It may be becoming more important than ever.
Stay connected with 2 Doctors & A Twist – Just What the Doctor Ordered!
- Subscribe on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you listen.
- Follow us on LinkedIn for clips, insights, and upcoming episodes.