Season's Savings | ₹5/mo for 3 months

₹199/month after first 3 months. Renews automatically. Terms apply.
Agree to Disagree About Gender cover art

Agree to Disagree About Gender

Agree to Disagree About Gender

Written by: Laura T and Yvette N
Listen for free

About this listen

Laura is an integrated trans woman. Yvette is gender critical.

They disagree on a lot when it comes to sex and gender, but agree it's better to talk about their differences and try to understand each other's perspective, rather than to assume the worst about each other.

Every week, they will have an open and civil discussion about current events pertaining to sex, gender and trans issues, and will have a civil and respectful discussion about contentious areas of disagreement

Hygiene & Healthy Living Social Sciences
Episodes
  • Episode 41 - Should A Trans Women Do Woman's Work - Steph Richards
    Oct 24 2026

    This week, we are joined by Steph Richards, a trans woman in her 70s who is the founder and chair of Translucent UK, a trans-led UK advocacy and human rights organization whose mission is to advance the visibility, social acceptance, legal recognition and healthcare of transgender and gender-diverse people.

    Through this organization recently has been focused on preserving the accommodations which trans people in the UK had previously enjoyed prior to the UK Supreme Court ruling which ruled that trans women are considered to be men in the application of the 2010 Equality Act, and on the implementation of the law regarding public sex-segregated spaces and services. She has become one of the more recognizable faces of trans advocacy in the UK, and has become a frequent target of criticism and vilification from gender critical advocates and the lay public She has also been extensively involved in women's health advocacy, and had previously served as head of Endometriosis South Coast UK, and prior to that had roles with other women's and children's health focused charities.

    Earlier, this year, she " faced public and poltiical criticism when she was appointed as a parliamentary liasion for Endometriosis South Coast, a non-public facing position. Suella Braverman, a prominent Reform UK Member of parliament, went as far as to call her appointment to this position "insulting and inappropriate", essentially forcing her to resign from this position. In spite of this, Richards remains a steadfast commitment to her cause, speaking publicly in defense of her positions in the mainstream media and on podcasts like our own

    In this episode, we discuss Richards's personal journey, her advocacy for trans people, and on the ethics and appropriateness of trans women being intimately involved in work involving conditions they cannot experience, and on one it mean to represent one's self as a woman's advocate as someone born male. We also discuss the health system implications of the UKSC ruling, and her concerns about how this will negatively impact the health and dignity of trans people seeking medical care in the UK.

    Show More Show Less
    1 hr and 53 mins
  • Episode 40 - Miranda Yardley - A Gender Apostate's Journey
    Oct 17 2026

    Miranda Yardley transitioned in the late 2000s, but by 2014 had become one of the earliest and prominent trans people in the UK to speak out against the excesses of "trans ideology" and in doing so, became a unique voice, a gender apostate embracing gender criticality.

    Over the years, she has written both in her own blogs and in prominent publications, and has appeared in mainstream media and podcasts discussing the role of autogynephilia in the genesis of trans identification, on the sanctity and necessity of women's only spaces, and on what she believes is the impingement of free speech and expression on by and on behalf of gender ideologues.

    When we invite guests on the program, we invite them to ask us questions as well, to consider their appearance more of a conversation than an interview, and Miranda more than took us up on the offer. In this episode, he discusses a wide range of topics with Laura and Yvette, including why he uses male pronouns and nominatives, why women tend to wear women's clothes, the threat posed by trans women (even Laura!) in women's spaces, and on the differences between compelled and suggested speech.

    The conversation often got heated, and occasionally impolitic, but these are the conversations that remain critically necessary

    Show More Show Less
    1 hr and 50 mins
  • Episode 39 - A British Physician Shares Her Concerns About Trans Issues - Dr. Alice Hodkinson
    Oct 11 2026

    Dr. Hodkinson is a UK-based general practitioner who has become a leading physician-advocate for gender critical causes, particularly on the intersection of trans identities and medicine.

    She and several other like minded UK-based physicians founded Biology in Medicine, where they posted anonymously out of concern that they would face social sanction from their colleagues and community for embracing gender critical views in a field that has a long history of being trans supportive, and where the efficacy and safety of transition-focused care and the health of trans and gender diverse populations were unexplored

    Dr. Hodkinson revealed her identity and her connection to Biology in Medicine recently, and has become the public face of this organization, appearing in print and social media. However, she has not before opened herself up for a discussion on a show where her views would receive serious scrutiny.

    In this wide-ranging conversation, we discuss the past and current climate for gender critical health care workers, and debate the efficacy of pediatric medical transition, the ethics of the ongoing puberty blocker trial, the controversies around inducing lactation in natal males (and natal female nongestational mothers), as well as the impact and dementia on identity in the aging transsexual.

    Show More Show Less
    1 hr and 56 mins
adbl_web_anon_alc_button_suppression_t1
No reviews yet