In this episode of Awakening Streams, Sensei Michael Brunner takes up Case 36 of the Book of Equanimity and Case 3 of the Blue Cliff Record, “Master Ma Is Unwell.”
The case is brief:
Great Master Ma is ill. A temple priest asks, “Oshō, how is your health these days?”
Master Ma replies:
“Sun-faced Buddha, moon-faced Buddha.”
From this short exchange, Sensei Michael explores what it means to meet life directly, without retreating into abstraction, story, or expectation.
The talk first places Master Ma, or Mazu Daoyi, in context as a legendary Zen teacher known for vigorous training methods, extraordinary presence, and deep ardor for the Dharma. But in this case, that larger-than-life figure is seriously ill and facing decline. His response, “Sun-faced Buddha, moon-faced Buddha,” draws on traditional names of Buddhas associated with radically different spans of life.
One lives for an immense period of time.
The other for only a day and a night.
The teaching is not about choosing one over the other.
It is about being awake to both.
Sensei Michael connects Master Ma’s response to the practice of equanimity, not as emotional distance or indifference, but as the ability to remain present with the full range of experience. Health and illness, strength and weakness, pleasure and pain, gain and loss all belong to the awakened way when they are met directly.
The talk then turns toward the question:
Who am I?
Practice brings us face-to-face not only with our ideals, but with the full complexity of ourselves: the monkey mind, the grasping mind, the saintly self, the difficult self, the part of us that gets things wrong.
Rather than rejecting those parts, Sensei Michael emphasizes learning to meet ourselves honestly and compassionately. Mistakes are not a reason to abandon practice. They are part of practice.
The teaching then moves into not knowing, self-trust, and the intimacy that appears when we loosen our fixed ideas about who we are. Drawing on Aitken Roshi and Taizan Maezumi, Sensei Michael reflects on the importance of trusting the very life through which realization occurs.
The second major question is:
“Is that so?”
To explore it, Sensei Michael recounts the well-known story of Zen Master Hakuin, who is falsely accused of fathering a child. Rather than defend his reputation or cling to his innocence, Hakuin simply responds, “Is that so?” He accepts responsibility for caring for the child, and when the truth is later revealed and the child is taken back, he again responds, “Is that so?”
The story becomes an example of what can remain when narrative, defensiveness, and self-protection fall away:
Compassion.
Compassion for the mother.
Compassion for the parents.
Compassion for the child.
Compassion for Hakuin himself.
The talk closes by returning to Master Ma.
Sun-faced Buddha. Moon-faced Buddha.
Both rise together.
Both belong to the awakened way.
The invitation is not to secure a life free from difficulty, but to remain open to the life that is actually here.
In this episode:
- Book of Equanimity Case 36
- Blue Cliff Record Case 3
- “Master Ma Is Unwell”
- Mazu Daoyi / Master Ma
- Sun-faced Buddha and moon-faced Buddha
- Equanimity and direct experience
- Practice beyond conceptual understanding
- “Who am I?”
- Making friends with yourself
- Mistakes and compassionate responsibility
- Not knowing
- Aitken Roshi and Taizan Maezumi
- Hakuin’s “Is that so?”
- Letting go of narrative
- Compassion as lived practice
- Training wholeheartedly
- “How are you spending this life?”
Awakening Streams is the podcast of One River Zen, featuring Zen Buddhist teachings, Dharma talks, koan commentary, meditation practice, and reflections on bringing practice into everyday life.
Learn more, practice with us, or support One River Zen at OneRiverZen.org.
🪷 Awakening Streams: The One River Zen Podcast
Teachings and reflections with Sensei Michael Brunner (Sōen) of One River Zen Center, 121 E Prospect St, Ottawa IL 61350.
🌐 Learn more & join practice: https://www.oneriverzen.org
🎧 Listen to more episodes: Awakening Streams Podcast
🙏 Support the Sangha: https://www.oneriverzen.org/donate
#SenseiMichaelBrunner #MichaelBrunnerOttawa #OneRiverZen #ZenKoan #ZenPodcast #OttawaIL #SotoZen