Season's Savings | ₹5/mo for 3 months

₹199/month after first 3 months. Renews automatically. Terms apply.
Big Isn't Rich. Rich Isn't Investable cover art

Big Isn't Rich. Rich Isn't Investable

Big Isn't Rich. Rich Isn't Investable

Listen for free

View show details
About this listen
Presented by YourCFOIn about five weeks, Southeast Asia’s two biggest growth stories swapped places.Vietnam got promoted by one of the big index providers. Indonesia got told by another that it might be pushed out of emerging markets altogether, and its stock market fell 11% in a day. Right in the middle of that, the IMF put out a forecast that says Vietnam’s income per person will pass Indonesia’s this year. First time ever.Meanwhile in Malaysia, where I’m based, the economy is growing at about five and a half percent. If you’re a founder in KL, you would never know it. And in the Philippines, the economy is having one of its worst years in a while, exports just hit an all-time record on AI chips, and the startup activity on the ground is better than the numbers suggest.None of that lines up the way you’d expect, and that’s the point. The size of an economy, the growth of an economy, and whether a startup in that economy can actually get funded and get bought are three different questions. We spent ten years treating them like one question.If you write cheques or raise them, this matters. Every seed round in this region is a bet on a buyer seven years from now. This month we got a clear look at who that buyer is, and where it’s getting harder to find.1. The crossoverThe IMF’s October World Economic Outlook projects Vietnam’s GDP per capita at about $5,260 this year, against about $5,150 for Indonesia. Last year Indonesia was about $250 ahead, and as of April the IMF still had Indonesia in front. In six months, the forecast flipped.The caveats, properly. These are nominal dollars, and the rupiah has been weak, so Indonesia looks a little worse after conversion. The gap is tiny, about two percent. This is a photo finish, not a lap. And Indonesia’s economy is still almost three times the size of Vietnam’s: about $1.5 trillion against about $540 billion. Indonesia isn’t shrinking into irrelevance.All true, and none of it changes the direction. Vietnam is growing a lot faster, and the IMF expects it to stay ahead next year. When you’re betting seven years out, direction matters more than size.Here’s why this one hits me personally. I have sat through hundreds of pitches where slide three is the market slide, and for Indonesia that slide wrote itself. 280 million people. Young. Mobile first. Every fund that raised for this region in the last decade had some version of it in its own LP deck.The thing that slide never said was how much money those 280 million people actually have. And whether there’s anyone at the end of the road who’ll buy the company you build to serve them.Big isn’t the same as rich. And it definitely isn’t the same as investable.Vietnam never had that slide. People called it the next China, but it ended up benefiting from the less sexy story: factories, the manufacturing shift, China plus one. The less sexy story compounded.2. Promoted and demotedNow the part that actually decides whether startups get paid: the markets.The quick version of how index providers work. MSCI and FTSE Russell sort every country’s stock market into buckets: developed, emerging, frontier, and a few that don’t fit anywhere get labelled standalone. Trillions of dollars of passive money, the index funds and ETFs, follow those buckets automatically. If you’re in the emerging bucket, emerging market funds have to own a slice of you. If you get moved out, they have to sell. No opinions involved. It’s the rule.So these aren’t academic labels. The bucket decides whether a huge pool of money is even allowed to show up.Vietnam first. FTSE Russell’s upgrade from frontier to secondary emerging took effect on 21 September and phases in through September 2027. MSCI hasn’t moved yet, but there’s a real chance it follows. How much money does it bring in? Estimates run from about one billion dollars to about six. When estimates are that far apart, nobody really knows. The direction isn’t in doubt: money is coming in, not going out.And that upgrade wasn’t luck. Vietnam spent years doing the boring work the index providers kept asking for: how foreign investors get access to the market, how trades settle. Nobody throws a party for the plumbing of a market. Vietnam did it anyway, and it got rewarded.Then Indonesia. On 15 October, MSCI opened a consultation on moving Indonesia from emerging to standalone. Not down to frontier. Standalone, below frontier, where almost nobody gets put.MSCI didn’t just say it didn’t like the vibes. It wrote down its reasons. Free float that isn’t really free: shares counted as being in public hands but actually held by people connected to the owners. Ownership structures you can’t see through. Trading in some stocks that looked coordinated. None of this came out of nowhere. MSCI froze changes to its Indonesian index back in January over the same concerns. Indonesia has been working on reforms all year, and MSCI acknowledged some progress ...
adbl_web_anon_alc_button_suppression_t1
No reviews yet