Season's Savings | ₹5/mo for 3 months

₹199/month after first 3 months. Renews automatically. Terms apply.
Everyone's a Critic in Philadelphia cover art

Everyone's a Critic in Philadelphia

Everyone's a Critic in Philadelphia

Written by: Kae Lani Palmisano
Listen for free

About this listen

What up, my Gourmet Jabronis! I’m your host, Kae Lani Palmisano, and Welcome to Everyone’s Critic in Philadelphia, the game show/talk show where the city’s most opinionated foodies square off to see who knows our restaurant scene best.

Here’s how the game works. We have two Philly tastemakers. They compete in three rounds of trivia and debates, and the person to rack up the most points — which I dish out randomly throughout the game — wins bragging rights and the coveted title of Toughest Critic!

Do you have the chops to be on the show? Apply to be a contestant by emailing me at everyonesacriticphl@gmail.com.

Potluck Productions, LLC
Art Cooking Food & Wine
Episodes
  • Eat Snick Snacks and Yip Yap With the Girlies
    Nov 18 2026

    Get in, dining divas! We're comparing tasting notes with gal pals Georgie Sipala (@thelonebruncher) and Sarah Silberg (@thecityspoon) on everything from dive-bar pasta and Indian takeout to swanky scoops of ice cream and skyline cocktails.

    Follow us on social!

    Everyone's a Critic in Philadelphia

    • TikTok: @everyonesacriticphl
    • Instagram: @everyonesacriticphl

    Kae Lani Palmisano

    • TikTok: @kaelanisays
    • Instagram: @kaelanisays

    Georgie Sipala

    • TikTok: @thelonebruncher
    • Instagram: @thelonebruncher

    Sarah Silberg

    • TikTok: @thecityspoon
    • Instagram: @thecityspoon

    If you'd like to be a contestant on the show, email everyonesacriticphl@gmail.com to apply.

    Show Notes:

    Music from #Uppbeat

    • Marameow Swing by Giulio Fazio
    • How Delightful by Jonny Boyle
    • Easy Breeze by RA
    • Anything is Right by Giulio Fazio
    • Guitars de France by Jonny Boyle
    • Cara Cara by Sky Toes

    Logo design by Nicole DiPonziano (@nicolediponziano)

    Show More Show Less
    35 mins
  • Scrooge McDuck's Money Pool, But Cheese Sauce
    Nov 4 2026

    In one corner, we have Natalia Lapore Hagan, host of Midnight Pasta, Philly's wildest pasta-making class and epic dinner party. In the other, Marcos Espinoza, the jerky junky behind Side Project Jerky. Two industry insiders join Kae Lani Palmisano in the ring, but only one can be crowned Philly's Toughest Critic!

    This week, Marcos shares his off-menu favorites, Natalia defends the hype over caviar, and we hear from listeners who voted in our new speed round, "The Greased Poll!"

    Follow us on social!

    Everyone's a Critic in Philadelphia

    • TikTok: @everyonesacriticphl
    • Instagram: @everyonesacriticphl

    Kae Lani Palmisano

    • TikTok: @kaelanisays
    • Instagram: @kaelanisays

    Natalia Lapore Hagan on Instagram

    • Personal IG: @natalialeporehagan
    • Midnight Pasta: @midnightpastaco

    Marcos Espinoza

    • Personal IG: @fidelgastro
    • Side Project Jerky: @sideprojectjerky

    If you'd like to be a contestant on the show, email everyonesacriticphl@gmail.com to apply.

    Show Notes:

    Music from #Uppbeat

    • Marameow Swing by Giulio Fazio
    • How Delightful by Jonny Boyle
    • Easy Breeze by RA
    • Anything is Right by Giulio Fazio
    • Crafty Crime by Jonny Boyle
    • Swingin' Sparks by Giulio Fazio
    • Go for the Gold by Richard Bodgers

    Logo design by Nicole DiPonziano (@nicolediponziano)

    Show More Show Less
    43 mins
  • The Choo Choo Train Place
    Oct 21 2026

    This week, Farah and Matt Vogel put their marriage to the test in Everyone's a Critic's very first lovers' quarrel. What are the rules for couples sharing food? Is pizza just a snack? Should you always order dessert? Listen and find out!

    Follow us on social!

    Everyone's a Critic in Philadelphia

    • TikTok: @everyonesacriticphl
    • Instagram: @everyonesacriticphl

    Kae Lani Palmisano

    • TikTok: @kaelanisays
    • Instagram: @kaelanisays

    Farah Vogel: @farahstacy

    Matt Vogel: @matteo_vogel

    If you'd like to be a contestant on the show, email everyonesacriticphl@gmail.com to apply.

    Show Notes:

    Music from #Uppbeat

    • Marameow Swing by Giulio Fazio
    • How Delightful by Jonny Boyle
    • Easy Breeze by RA
    • Jazz Rumble by Airstream
    • Get Wacky! by Giulio Fazio
    • Crafty Crime by Jonny Boyle

    Logo design by Nicole DiPonziano (@nicolediponziano)

    Show More Show Less
    33 mins
adbl_web_anon_alc_button_suppression_t1
No reviews yet