Something rather unexpected has happened in American politics. Christianity, which for decades has been closely associated with the Republican Party and the Religious Right, is making its presence felt on the Democratic side. And not merely with politicians who happen to attend church occasionally. These are people who are putting Jesus, the Bible and Christian teaching at the centre of their political arguments.
In this episode of Gerry & Pete, we examine the remarkable results of the 2026 US midterm elections, the resurgence of the Christian Left, and one rather awkward question: can you tax people into loving their neighbour?
In Texas, James Talarico, a Presbyterian seminarian and former teacher, defeated Republican Ken Paxton to become the state's first elected Democratic US senator since 1988. His campaign drew heavily on the teachings of Jesus, particularly the command to love your neighbour.
Meanwhile, in Kansas, Adam Hamilton, a Methodist megachurch pastor, defeated Republican Senator Roger Marshall. Kansas hadn't elected a Democrat to the US Senate since 1932. Something is certainly stirring.
But what exactly?
Talarico argues that Christians shouldn't merely give charity to poor people. They should challenge the political and economic systems that make such charity necessary. That means looking at taxation, healthcare, inequality, welfare provision and the responsibilities of government.
It's an interesting argument. And one that deserves rather more consideration than simply shouting socialism or Christian nationalism across the political divide, which is increasingly how sophisticated political debate appears to work.
What does the Bible actually teach about wealth, poverty and social justice?
Jesus told the parable of the Good Samaritan, who personally helped a wounded stranger. The early Christians shared their possessions and provided for those in need. The Old Testament prophets condemned exploitation, corruption and unjust laws.
But does any of this amount to a biblical mandate for wealth redistribution through government taxation? Is compulsory taxation an expression of Christian generosity, or does genuine charity have to be voluntary?
And, come to think of it, what is the proper relationship between Christianity and government in the first place?
We explore the American Constitution, the beliefs of the Founding Fathers, and the remarkable observation by President John Adams that the Constitution was designed for a moral and religious people. Can a democratic society maintain its freedoms without the moral foundations that originally sustained them?
There's another question, perhaps an even more important one.
Is social justice the Gospel?
Christians are commanded to care for the poor, defend the vulnerable and love their neighbours. But Christianity is not simply a programme for improving society. At its centre stands Jesus Christ, crucified and risen, calling people to repentance, faith and new life.
Can the Christian Left lose sight of that? Certainly. But can the Christian Right become so absorbed in political power and cultural battles that it, too, loses sight of the Gospel? That's a question worth asking.
We also consider the Kingdom of God, the relationship between Church and State, personal responsibility, Christian charity, economic justice and whether Jesus can legitimately be claimed by either side of America's increasingly bitter political divide.
Perhaps the real problem isn't that Christianity has become too political. Perhaps it's that politics has become rather too confident about deciding what Christianity ought to mean.
And the question remains:
Does Jesus belong to the Left, the Right, or does he challenge both?
#GerryAndPete #ChristianityAndPolitics #ChristianLeft #ChristianRight #USElections2026 #JamesTalarico #AdamHamilton #SocialJustice #ChristianPolitics #Bible #Gospel #DonaldTrump #FaithAndPolitics