Season's Savings | ₹5/mo for 3 months

₹199/month after first 3 months. Renews automatically. Terms apply.
Is Logic Possible Without God? cover art

Is Logic Possible Without God?

Is Logic Possible Without God?

Listen for free

View show details
About this listen
WATCH NOW ON YOUTUBE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Oflpu2_m9qg SUBSCRIBE TO CHRIS'S BIBLE NEWSLETTER https://chrissbiblenewsletter.org/subscribe SUPPORT THE NEWSLETTER https://support.chrissbiblenewsletter.org FULL BIBLE STUDY ARTICLE [youtube https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Oflpu2_m9qg%5D Listen to the Podcast Support the Newsletter My Book Recommendations Is logic possible without God? The moment an atheist accuses someone of being illogical, he's made a statement that presupposes the truth of God. So what is tag or the transcendental argument for God? This asserts that objective, logic, reason, and epistemology, how we know what we know, they're all contingent upon God's existence. So to deny his his existence is to undermine the very foundation of reasoning itself. And we're going to discuss this here a few parts. What are we going to go over? First, what the transcendental argument actually claims. This is interesting. Number two, why logic requires a trans transcendent basis. Number three, how tag is used as a gotcha in debates for the specific summoner form of the argument and why the triune god is often mentioned as a precondition with some common rebuttals, why they’re faulty, some evaluation as well. We’re going to get into here at the end when we answer some questions. So, let's get started. The transcendental argument. This is different from most arguments from cause and effect. Okay, from this perspective, it is a transcendental argument which means it asks what must be true in order for something else to be true. So what does the argument claim? that the abstract universal logic laws non-contradiction law of excluded middle law of identity are not derived from or contingent upon the physical world because those are specific because those are specific variable things. We see this in John 1:1. Instead, these objective logical laws must have a source in something universal and necessary. The only answer that makes sense is that God is the source of these rational laws. So tag, it's an argument from reason, not an argument from revelation. Now, part number two, why does logic need a foundation? Most atheists are dualists in the in the philosophical sense. Examining the Argument So what what does this mean? They consider logic to be a human convention or merely an observation of naturally occurring phenomena. Either way, it is something that can be changed or that changes as our civilization evolves. Logic cannot be arbitrary or relative if it is to have any meaning at all. Okay? If it is a convention essentially then it has no epistemic authority. Objective and Subjective Morality If it is an emergent property of matter it cannot be universal or necessary. These viewpoints would suggest that there's no such thing as objective truth only subjective ideas of truth. This cannot be the case as we see in Romans 1:20. What does it say? God has revealed himself in ways that make mankind without excuse. So, moving forward from that, before we tie this together, how tag is used as a gotcha in debates. And before we jump into this, if you could click the subscribe button, like the episode, it really does help. It only takes a few seconds. It’s free for you to do this. And each new subscriber we get, it does help the content reach more people and help more people get the message, which I think is important. So, thank you for your support. Now, you are probably familiar with these kinds of debates. One Christian gets an atheist on a point. The atheist concedes the debate. It seems like a gotcha moment, right? Too many. But that's basically what TAG is designed to do. It highlights the subtle but missing logical inconsistency between a naturalistic atheist's belief in logic and his unbelief in God. It doesn't prove God's existence in the same way that a fossil might prove evolution, but it does show that atheists are logically inconsistent in their worldview. They use the same logical laws that they claim don't exist. Now, what is the specific summoner? Okay, the the summoner form we mentioned earlier. One variation of tag is sometimes referred to as the summoner argument. This argument basically takes the same form as the primary argument but is phrased a little bit differently. It begins with a hypothetical question. If an atheist were to make a true statement, what would that mean? Then the argument goes on to say that making a true or false statement at all affirms that the listener is using the abstract. So what does this mean? universal logical laws are being used to interpret the speaker's words. The only sufficient basis for these kinds of unchanging universal laws is a transcendent being with a mind to comprehend them, which would essentially be God. If an atheist denies this, he's claiming that he has knowledge that he cannot have. Colossians 2:3 is an effective reply to this argument essentially that all treasures of wisdom and knowledge are found in Jesus. So moving on, why the triune ...
adbl_web_anon_alc_button_suppression_t1
No reviews yet