Episode Description
The email subject line says "Quick question before I move forward." It isn't a question. It's a decision your director of programs already owns, sent back for your sign-off. It's also the third one this week.
Brooke Richie-Babbage calls this the boomerang effect, and she argues that most executive directors misdiagnose it. Brooke names the pattern she sees most often underneath it, which she calls borrowed authority.
Key Questions Answered
- Why do delegated decisions keep coming back to the executive director?
- Why does my leadership team keep asking for approval on decisions they own?
- Is my director the wrong hire, or is it a structural problem?
- How do I know whether my leadership team has a skills gap or a decision-rights gap?
Key Takeaways
- Delegation that holds is a structural achievement, not a personality trait. Brooke Richie-Babbage has watched committed micromanagers learn to delegate well once they're working inside a structure they trust to produce good results.
- Borrowed authority shows up at the edges of a director's lane, not in the middle of it. Capable directors escalate decisions involving money, external relationships, and anything the board might ask about, because accountability there still feels like it belongs to the executive director.
- Misreading borrowed authority as a skills gap sends resources in the wrong direction. Leaders end up developing competencies their directors already have instead of co-creating the decision structures they actually need.
- Fixing nonprofit delegation means designing ownership into roles on purpose. Each director needs to know what is theirs to decide and exactly where their authority ends, defined more clearly than feels necessary.
FAQs
What is borrowed authority in a nonprofit leadership team? Borrowed authority is a delegation pattern Brooke Richie-Babbage identifies in growing nonprofits. A director holds responsibility for an outcome but behaves as if the authority to act is on loan from the executive director, one decision at a time. Each new decision renews the loan, so the director checks in before acting, even on decisions clearly within their role.
Why do delegated decisions keep coming back to the executive director? Delegated decisions return to nonprofit executive directors mainly because of structure, not personality. According to Brooke Richie-Babbage, when roles don't define decision rights and where a director's authority ends, checking in becomes the rational choice. Directors escalate at the edges of their lanes, such as money and board-visible decisions, where accountability feels like it still belongs to the ED.
What is the boomerang effect in delegation? The boomerang effect is Brooke Richie-Babbage's term for a decision that returns to the executive director after being clearly delegated. It often arrives as a “quick question before I move forward” email that is really a request for approval. When it happens across more than one director, it points to a structural problem rather than a hiring mistake.
Resources Mentioned: Black Friday 5 Days of Deals early list — https://go.brookerichiebabbage.com/bf26earlylist — Early access to all five Deal Week offers, plus early-list gifts. Deal Week starts Monday, November 23.
Want to work together?
Apply for the Next Level Nonprofit Mastermind, a high-touch coaching and training accelerator for established organizations with $1M+ budgets that are ready to design for impact sustained at scale.
Budget under $1M? Join Elevate and get proven step-by-step playbooks + coaching support to build each of the core elements of your nonprofit's operating system - strategic clarity, a fundraising engine, a high-performance team, and an active and engaged board!
Connect with me!