Season's Savings | ₹5/mo for 3 months

₹199/month after first 3 months. Renews automatically. Terms apply.
One Market on Paper. Six in Real Life. cover art

One Market on Paper. Six in Real Life.

One Market on Paper. Six in Real Life.

Listen for free

View show details
About this listen
Presented by YourCFONext week there is going to be a very big press release.From the 15th to the 17th of November, ASEAN’s leaders meet in Manila for the 49th ASEAN Summit. The Philippines is chairing this year, and the headline deliverable, the thing everyone has been working towards, is that they are due to sign something called DEFA: the ASEAN Digital Economy Framework Agreement.You are going to see the photos. Leaders in a row, matching shirts, pens on the table. You are going to see the phrase “world’s first region-wide digital economy agreement.” And you are going to see a number: that this deal could take the region’s digital economy from about one trillion dollars to two trillion by 2030.I want to get to this before the ceremony, not after. Because once the photos are out, everyone will tell you this is the moment Southeast Asia became one market for startups. It isn’t. I don’t say that to be cynical. There is something real in this deal, and I will tell you exactly where. But if you are a founder planning your expansion around a signing ceremony, you are going to plan it wrong.One. What they’re actually signingThe short version: DEFA is a regional agreement that tries to make it easier to do digital business across all ten ASEAN countries. Payments that work across borders. E-invoices and trade documents one country accepts from another. Digital identity. Rules for moving data across borders. Cybersecurity. E-commerce. And some newer ground: AI, fintech, and protection for your source code, so a government cannot make you hand it over as a condition of doing business.The longer version, because the timeline matters. Negotiations launched in September 2023 and concluded at the end of May this year, at a meeting of senior officials in Manila. Every member state has since been doing a legal review of the text. Signing is scheduled for next week. After signing, each country has to ratify it, with a target of 180 days.So best case, you are looking at the middle of next year before it is even in force across the region. And in force is not the same as your customer’s bank, your customer’s tax office and your customer’s regulator all changing how they work. That is implementation, and implementation is where the real time goes.Two caveats. First, the final text is not public yet. Civil society groups have complained about exactly that, and they have a point. Most of what you will read next week, including from me, is built on summaries, law-firm notes and what officials have said in public. Hold it all a little loosely.Second, that two-trillion-dollar number. It comes from a study done for the negotiations. I am not saying it is wrong. I am saying a study that tells the people who commissioned it that their project will double the economy is not the most independent research you will read this year. It’s a slide, not a forecast.Here is what is genuinely good about it, and I want to be fair. This is ten very different countries agreeing, in writing, on the direction of travel. Data should flow. Payments should connect. E-invoices should be recognised. Source code should not be a bargaining chip. For a region that has historically agreed on very little in tech, that matters. It tells regulators which way to lean when they write the next rule. This is a fragmented market, and anything that defragments it is welcome.But direction is not the same thing as a market.Two. We’ve signed this beforeIf you have been around this region long enough, this will feel familiar. The ASEAN Economic Community launched at the end of 2015: a single market and production base, free flow of goods, services, investment and skilled labour. I remember the conference panels. I remember the decks. It was going to change everything.In 2019 the region signed an ASEAN agreement on electronic commerce. That one took until the end of 2021 to come into force.Now ask yourself honestly. If you are a founder in Kuala Lumpur selling software to a customer in Jakarta today, how much did either of those agreements change your week? Your contracts, your tax, your payment collection, your data setup?For almost every founder I know, the answer is: not much. Not because the agreements were bad, but because an agreement between governments sets the direction, and then every country implements it through its own laws, its own regulators and its own politics. The treaty is the easy bit. The six separate rulebooks underneath it are the hard bit.Three. Six rulebooks, six lawyersHere is the detail I really want founders to hear. From the legal analysis I have seen, DEFA does not automatically override national data rules, and it does not override data localisation. Each country keeps its own. That is how treaties usually interact with national law, and there is no sign this one is different.Two examples, used as a regional pattern, not to pick on anyone. Indonesia has had a regulation since 2019 that separates public and ...
adbl_web_anon_alc_button_suppression_t1
No reviews yet