Season's Savings | ₹5/mo for 3 months

₹199/month after first 3 months. Renews automatically. Terms apply.
Pretty Evil cover art

Pretty Evil

Pretty Evil

Written by: Jessica Strohm
Listen for free

About this listen

Pretty Evil is a psychology-driven true crime podcast exploring the uncomfortable realities hiding behind human behavior.


Each episode examines the psychological forces that shape destructive human behavior, from charismatic predators and cult leaders to institutional failures, social influence, moral panic, and the hidden mechanisms that allow harm to flourish.


Through immersive storytelling and psychosocial analysis, Pretty Evil explores what these cases reveal about power, vulnerability, identity, persuasion, and the darker parts of human nature.

© 2026 Pretty Evil Media
Science Social Sciences True Crime
Episodes
  • Fraternity Hazing: Dying to Belong
    Nov 17 2026

    Send us Fan Mail

    Every year, college students willingly endure humiliation, physical abuse, and dangerous initiation rituals for the chance to belong to a fraternity. Some of those rituals have ended in tragedy. So why does hazing continue, even when everyone knows how dangerous it can be?

    In this episode of Pretty Evil, we investigate the disturbing culture of fraternity hazing in American colleges, exploring the psychology of group belonging, conformity, obedience, and the social pressures that can turn good, well-meaning young adults into participants in extraordinary cruelty.

    Fraternities promise brotherhood, lifelong friendships, and a sense of community. But behind some of those promises lies a tradition of initiation rituals that can involve forced alcohol consumption, psychological humiliation, sleep deprivation, and physical violence. Despite decades of public scrutiny, anti-hazing policies, and high-profile student deaths, dangerous hazing practices have persisted.

    We'll examine the circumstances surrounding deadly fraternity hazing incidents, the social structures that allow abusive traditions to survive, and the difficult questions of responsibility when an entire group participates in behavior that individuals might otherwise recognize as unacceptable.

    But the psychology behind hazing extends far beyond Greek life.

    Why are we sometimes willing to endure mistreatment to gain acceptance? And why do people who have experienced that mistreatment so often become the ones who later inflict it on others?

    Through the lenses of social identity theory, conformity, cognitive dissonance, and group dynamics, we'll explore how the desire to belong can influence our judgment, how initiation rituals can become embedded in a group's identity, and why the promise of brotherhood can make it difficult to challenge harmful traditions.

    We'll also consider the role of bystanders, institutional accountability, and the psychological mechanisms that allow people to rationalize cruelty when it's presented as tradition, loyalty, or a necessary step toward acceptance.

    Ultimately, fraternity hazing raises an uncomfortable question about human behavior: How much are we willing to sacrifice to belong, and what might we be willing to do to someone else once we're on the inside?

    Pretty Evil is a true crime and behavioral psychology podcast exploring disturbing stories, the people behind them, and what they reveal about the world around us—and sometimes ourselves.

    Topics covered: Fraternity hazing, college hazing deaths, Greek life, fraternity initiation rituals, hazing psychology, college fraternities, toxic brotherhood, social identity theory, conformity, cognitive dissonance, groupthink, peer pressure, bystander effect, institutional accountability, criminal psychology, true crime, psychology of belonging.

    Support the show

    Some details don't make it into the episode. For source material, research files, episode extras, and more to the story, visit prettyevilpodcast.com.

    Show More Show Less
    1 hr and 8 mins
  • Belle Gibson: "Trust Me, I'm Dying"
    Nov 9 2026

    Send us Fan Mail

    Belle Gibson claimed she had terminal brain cancer. She told millions of people she'd survived without conventional medical treatment, relying instead on a healthy diet, natural remedies, and alternative therapies. There was just one problem: she never had cancer.

    By the time the truth emerged, the Australian wellness influencer had built a lucrative brand around her extraordinary survival story, launched the bestselling recipe app The Whole Pantry, published a cookbook, and convinced countless followers that her approach to wellness could accomplish what modern medicine supposedly couldn't.

    In this episode of Pretty Evil, we investigate the true story of Belle Gibson, the Australian wellness entrepreneur whose fabricated cancer diagnosis became one of the most notorious health fraud scandals of the social media era.

    We'll explore how Gibson transformed her supposed battle with terminal brain cancer into a successful wellness empire, why her claims resonated with an audience increasingly interested in natural healing, and how journalists eventually uncovered the inconsistencies behind her story.

    We'll also examine the psychological forces that helped her deception flourish, from the persuasive power of personal testimonials and the appeal of miraculous recovery stories to the ways social media rewards vulnerability, authenticity, and perceived expertise.

    But the Belle Gibson scandal raises a more complicated question than simply why someone would lie about having cancer.

    Why were so many people willing to believe her, and what happens when someone's personal story becomes more persuasive than medical evidence?

    As we follow Gibson's rise and fall, we'll consider the relationship between identity, deception, public sympathy, and the wellness industry's complicated relationship with scientific authority. We'll also examine the consequences of her false claims, the Australian legal proceedings that followed, and the uncomfortable questions surrounding accountability when misinformation is packaged as inspiration.

    The story of Belle Gibson is particularly relevant in an era when health advice, personal branding, and influencer culture are increasingly intertwined. Her success reveals how easily an emotionally compelling narrative can acquire the appearance of credibility, especially when the person telling it seems to embody everything their audience hopes is possible.

    And it leaves us with a question worth asking whenever we encounter an extraordinary claim online: Are we evaluating the reality of the situation, or are we responding to how much we want the story to be true?

    Pretty Evil explores true crime, psychological manipulation, deception, and the human behavior behind some of the world's most disturbing stories.

    Topics covered: Belle Gibson, Belle Gibson cancer fraud, The Whole Pantry, Apple Cider Vinegar Netflix series, Australian wellness influencer, fake cancer diagnosis, wellness industry, health misinformation, alternative medicine, medical misinformation, influencer deception, social media psychology, psychological manipulation, fraud, cancer scams, wellness culture, true crime podcast.

    Support the show

    Some details don't make it into the episode. For source material, research files, episode extras, and more to the story, visit prettyevilpodcast.com.

    Show More Show Less
    1 hr and 22 mins
  • The Monsters Study: Authority, Identity & The Stories We Inherit About Ourselves
    Nov 3 2026

    Send us Fan Mail

    In 1939, researchers at the University of Iowa conducted a disturbing psychology experiment on 22 children at an Iowa orphanage. Six children who spoke normally were repeatedly told they were developing a stutter. The experiment became known as the Monster Study, one of the most controversial examples of unethical psychological research in American history.

    But did the Monster Study actually cause children to develop speech disorders? And what happens when someone in a position of authority convinces a child that something is wrong with them?

    In this episode of Pretty Evil, we investigate the true story of the Monster Study, a 1939 speech pathology experiment conducted by graduate student Mary Tudor under the supervision of psychologist Wendell Johnson at the University of Iowa.

    Johnson, who had struggled with stuttering throughout his own childhood, wanted to challenge prevailing theories about the origins of speech disorders. He believed that repeatedly labeling normal childhood speech difficulties as stuttering might actually contribute to the development of the condition.

    To test that theory, Tudor divided 22 children at the Iowa Soldiers' Orphans' Home into four groups. Some received positive reinforcement about their speech, while others were subjected to criticism and negative labeling. Six children who had no identified stutter were repeatedly warned that they were developing one, and the adults responsible for their care were encouraged to reinforce that message.

    The experiment continued for months, but the results were far more complicated than the story most people have heard.

    We'll examine the original research findings, why later analysis found no evidence that the experiment caused stuttering, and the troubling behavioral changes documented in Tudor's own notes. We'll also explore why the study remained unpublished for decades, the investigative reporting that brought it to public attention in 2001, and the lawsuit that ultimately resulted in a $925,000 settlement with the state of Iowa.

    But beyond the ethical failures of the experiment lies a psychological question that reaches far beyond the laboratory: How much of our identity is shaped by what other people repeatedly tell us about ourselves?

    Through the psychology of labeling, authority, self-perception, and internalized expectations, we'll explore how children learn to understand themselves through the reactions of others, why certain labels can become difficult to question, and how even well-intentioned judgments can influence the stories we carry about who we are.

    The Monster Study raises important questions about research ethics, the responsibilities of people in positions of authority, and the lasting consequences of being taught to doubt something that once came naturally.

    And it leaves us with a question w

    We're Obsessed With You
    Join Emily & Kyle as they dive into their favorite personalities's current hyper-fixations

    Listen on: Apple Podcasts Spotify

    Support the show

    Some details don't make it into the episode. For source material, research files, episode extras, and more to the story, visit prettyevilpodcast.com.

    Show More Show Less
    32 mins
adbl_web_anon_alc_button_suppression_t1
No reviews yet