You're the best coder on the team. You're brilliant at what you do.
So we promote you, give you seven people to lead, and still expect you to be the best coder.
What could possibly go wrong?
In Episode 5 of The Irrelevant Leader Podcast, Adam Piercy and Phil Jewell explore one of the biggest mistakes organizations make: promoting people into leadership roles without preparing them to actually lead.
They challenge the assumption that career progression should always mean managing people, discuss why organizations need different pathways for technical experts and leaders, and explore how AI might reshape the way we think about organizational structures.
But the conversation also gets personal.
Phil shares the frustrations he experienced after leaving the military, including a particularly difficult leadership role that challenged his confidence and sense of identity. He explains how journaling helped him process those experiences and ultimately led to the creation of The Irrelevant Leader.
Adam and Phil also discuss accountability, organizational culture, the danger of tolerating toxic behaviour because someone delivers technical results, and why curiosity is one of the most important skills any leader can develop.
Because being good at your job doesn't automatically make you good at leading people.
And if we expect people to lead, we need to prepare them to lead.
In this episode
- Why promoting your best individual contributor doesn't automatically create a great leader
- The challenge of expecting someone to remain a technical expert while also leading a team
- Why first-level leadership can be some of the most difficult leadership
- The career ladder versus the career lattice: creating progression without forcing people into management
- Why leadership isn't limited to people with formal authority
- How everyone contributes to an organization's culture and standards
- The experiences and frustrations that led Phil to develop The Irrelevant Leader
- How journaling helped Phil navigate a particularly lonely period of leadership
- Why being the leader people need sometimes means not being the leader they want
- The dangers of tolerating toxic behaviour because someone delivers excellent technical results
- Why curiosity, asking questions, and admitting you don't know are essential leadership skills
Episode chapters
00:00 — Welcome to Episode 5: The individual contributor dilemma
01:38 — What happens when your best performer gets promoted?
02:37 — Can someone be a technical expert and a leader at the same time?
03:41 — Becoming irrelevant is a journey, not an overnight transition
04:48 — What should newly promoted leaders do first?
05:02 — Why we need to train leaders earlier in their careers
06:30 — The career lattice versus the leadership ladder
08:40 — Creating technical and leadership pathways for progression
09:59 — You don't need a management position to demonstrate leadership
11:06 — Leading and influencing people who don't report to you
12:27 — Everyone is responsible for organizational culture and standards
13:22 — The experiences that inspired The Irrelevant Leader
14:02 — Phil's frustrations with conventional leadership development
16:30 — How a difficult leadership role and journaling led to the business
18:11 — Resetting standards in a resistant organizational culture
20:12 — Being the leader people need, not necessarily the leader they want
21:11 — Leadership loneliness, self-belief, and the importance of reflection
22:21 — Accountability and organizational culture
23:29 — When technical competence becomes an excuse for toxic behaviour
24:14 — Quick-fire questions: Experts, curiosity, and asking questions
26:18 — Final takeaway: Don't promote leaders without preparing them
Learn more
Explore The Irrelevant Leader book, keynote, and leadership development programs at theirrelevantleader.com.