Episodes

  • Skyedive: Who Stole Evangelicalism & Why Fallen Pastors Keep Coming Back
    Nov 13 2026

    Is evangelicalism worth defending, or has fundamentalism taken over the movement? Skye reflects on his conversation with Bonnie Kristian and invites listeners to share what they still value about evangelicalism. He also responds to Esau McCaulley's comments about disqualifying pastors from ministry, arguing that evangelical churches have lowered the standards for pastoral leadership while elevating pastors to celebrity status. Finally, Skye looks at ten differences between evangelicalism and fundamentalism identified by theologian John Stott and asks whether the evangelical label is still worth saving.

    Share your defense of evangelicalism at holypost.com/yourtake

    0:01 - Theme Song

    3:10 - How Would You Defend Evangelicalism?

    9:44 - Pastor Infidelity

    16:00 - Is the Pastor a Sacrament?

    22:50 - Lowered Bar for Pastors

    25:13 - This episode is available only for Holy Post Plus subscribers. Not a subscriber? Head on over to: https://holypost.substack.com/publish/post/224672101?r=35kf51&utm_campaign=post-expanded-share&utm_medium=web

    Judson's Taylor's take on if Fundamentalists have taken over evangelicalism:

    https://judsontaylor.substack.com/p/have-fundamentalists-taken-over-evangelicalism

    Show More Show Less
    26 mins
  • Drew's News: Outrage Over The Chosen's Angels, Halloween Dad's Meltdown, & Evangelical Water
    Nov 6 2026

    Skye talks with Drew Dyck about strange stories from around the web. The trailer for season six of "The Chosen" reveals Native American and Asian angels. Is it "forced diversity," a Mormon dog whistle, or something even more sinister? They unpack the ridiculous controversy. What does the daily schedule of James Bond author Ian Fleming teach us about creativity? A dad goes nuclear when he finds a gospel message in his son's Halloween candy, leading Skye to talk about the ordinary challenges of pluralism. Does reading Paul's letters in the New Testament in a different order reveal something about the apostle's transformation over time? And have we unknowingly confused Christianity with evangelical culture?

    0:02 - Theme Song

    3:31 - The Chosen's Unconventional Angels

    9:36 - Is Racism Behind the Backlash?

    18:58 - Representing Jesus as Other Races or Genders?

    27:26 - This episode is available only for Holy Post Plus subscribers. Not a subscriber? Head on over to: https://holypost.substack.com/p/99081976-2de3-4688-9f7a-8cf4e15d874a?postPreview=free&updated=2026-11-05T22%3A10%3A20.551Z&audience=only_paid&free_preview=true&freemail=true

    Articles and Stories Mentioned:

    The Chosen's Unconventional Angels:

    https://churchleaders.com/news/2224952-the-chosen-angels-native-american.html?utm_medium=email&_hsenc=p2ANqtz-9Po2FYSHkZ6hH3f84VPjLseh3fHOpSQLJ-w_IWlkO9ne1Ti_JO9NNQH1YwWVSW1siWWeO8L-4b7JKogKWx48Gfo0-rGw&_hsmi=447763409&utm_content=447763409&utm_source=hs_email

    Explosion over Halloween pamphlets;

    https://nypost.com/2026/11/04/us-news/washington-dad-who-exploded-after-finding-christian-pamphlets-in-sons-trick-or-treat-bag-now-accuses-neighbors-of-grooming/

    Paul's Letters in Order:

    https://biblesecrets.substack.com/p/read-pauls-letters-in-order-something

    Ian Fleming's Writing Routine:

    https://www.yahoo.com/lifestyle/articles/sir-ian-fleming-had-best-201700133.html

    Swimming in Evangelical Water:

    https://mereorthodoxy.com/swimming-in-evangelical-water/

    Show More Show Less
    28 mins
  • French Friday: Can Democrats Close the "God Gap"?
    Oct 30 2026

    All signs point to a big mid-term election for Democrats, but much will depend on their ability to win over religious voters. David French and Skye Jethani discuss the political "God gap," and why religious Americans of all types have moved toward the Republican Party since the 1980s. French reports on his recent trip to Texas, the Senate race between Paxton and Talarico, and why the state's most famous pro-Trump pastor is giving his church permission not to vote Republican. They discuss why Democrats, until recently, have struggled to use moral rhetoric. And why have pro-ICE, anti-empathy Christians on social media suddenly changed their tune?

    0:00 - Theme Song

    0:32 - Midterms

    15:47 - Voting on Doctrine?

    26:12 - Did Robert Jeffress Change His Mind?

    41:23 - Democrats Talking Like Republicans

    51:16 - Samuel Sey and Ice

    1:10:22 - End Credit

    The Return of Moralistic Democrats:

    https://www.theatlantic.com/books/2026/10/midterm-elections-and-return-of-good-and-evil/689145/

    David French on the God Gap:

    https://www.nytimes.com/2026/10/04/opinion/talarico-paxton-texas-senate-evangelicals.html

    David French on Empathy and Immigration:

    https://www.nytimes.com/2026/10/29/opinion/toxic-empathy-immigration-ice.html

    Hannah Miller King on Pregnant Women in ICE Detention Centers:

    https://holypost.substack.com/p/ice-vs-the-unborn

    Show More Show Less
    1 hr and 11 mins
  • SkyeDive: There's Something Better Than Mountaintop Christianity
    Oct 23 2026

    Why do we experience powerful moments with God—then go back to our normal lives, unchanged? Skye explains why we, like Moses, lose the effects of God's glory and how the New Covenant offers us a way out of the cycle of mountain-top highs and spiritually-empty lows.

    0:00 - Intro

    4:08 - Theme Song

    4:24 - Sermon Starts

    9:34 - Down from the Mountaintop

    14:05 - Was Moses Hiding Behind the Veil?

    18:30 - This episode is available only for Holy Post Plus subscribers. Not a subscriber? Head on over to: https://holypost.substack.com/p/becd0d4d-939c-44b8-bad1-fabe22fae3cf?postPreview=free&updated=2026-10-22T17%3A59%3A18.098Z&audience=only_paid&free_preview=true&freemail=true

    Show More Show Less
    19 mins
  • Drew's News: Sex Recession, Beautiful Math, and Punk Rock Narnia
    Oct 16 2026

    Drew, King of the North, brings his royal decrees and news from around the internet. He and Skye wonder why religious couples seem to be insulated from the sex recession. Does it all come back to smartphones? Then they talk about how AI is pushing people to find meaning and purpose outside of their vocations. And why does Skye seem less excited about Greta Gerwig's rock-infused Narnia than Drew is? All that, and Skye explains why he thinks Anthropic is a little like Uncle Buck.

    0:01 - Theme Song

    2:08 - Christians Resisted the Sex Recession?

    8:14 - Why Religion Helps Sex

    17:59 - Mathemeticians Look for God

    26:44 - This episode is available only for Holy Post Plus subscribers. Not a subscriber? Head on over to: https://holypost.substack.com/p/6ec53a32-f8e6-46ae-a7dc-252b05bb6494?postPreview=free&updated=2026-10-15T18%3A41%3A00.353Z&audience=only_paid&free_preview=true&freemail=true

    Articles:

    The Sex Recession: https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/2026/09/religion-sex-recession-marriage/688774/

    AI Mathematician on The Meaning of Life: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/when-a-i-comes-for-your-purpose-in-life/id1200361736?i=1000796109623

    New Narnia Trailer: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gDJ-ini7fF0

    Article on AI and the Church: https://holypost.substack.com/p/this-is-not-a-drill

    Show More Show Less
    27 mins
  • Air Mail: Repentance, Gehenna, and Circumcision
    Oct 9 2026

    Skye sifts through your questions, like panning for gold! Or, cleaning the gunk from your dishwasher, depending on your perspective. Mailman Mike's brought Skye questions about what repentance means, how we should respond to historically-questionable-sermon-illustrations, and if we take scripture-reading too seriously. Plus—what are women supposed to feel about all this talk about male circumcision in the Bible?

    0:07 - Theme Song

    2:13 - Repenting of Trump?

    8:35 - Gehenna

    17:17 - Sermon on the Mount: Serious and Literal?

    30:44 - How Important is Scripture-reading?

    31:44 - This episode is available only for Holy Post Plus subscribers. Not a subscriber? Head on over to: https://holypost.substack.com/p/5f17706f-3b89-4901-b1ed-a903f2638ffc?postPreview=free&updated=2026-10-08T20%3A21%3A26.549Z&audience=only_paid&free_preview=true&freemail=true

    Questions Answered:

    • What did Skye mean when he said Christians should repent of supporting Trump?
    • Was Gehenna actually a trash-pit outside Jerusalem?
    • How do you take the Sermon on the Mount seriously?
    • Do we overemphasize scripture reading?
    • Do men know how alienating discussions of circumcision are to women?
    • How bad are the bears gonna be this year?
    Show More Show Less
    32 mins
  • Spectacle vs Subtlety
    Oct 2 2026

    When Jesus raised Lazarus from the dead, it was his most public and spectacular miracle ever. But why were most of his miracles before this marked by secrecy and subtlety instead? In this message, Skye explores the role spectacles play in our faith, why we are so drawn to them, and why they usually fail to foster a transformative, sustainable love for God.

    0:00 - Preamble

    1:21 - Theme Song

    1:52 - American Duels

    6:46 - Lazarus and Duels

    10:39 - How Jesus Creates Spectacle

    16:04 - This episode is available only for Holy Post Plus subscribers. Not a subscriber? Head on over to: https://holypost.substack.com/p/f8df4b24-a965-417a-803a-56d559e03a56?postPreview=free&updated=2026-10-01T19%3A24%3A32.487Z&audience=only_paid&free_preview=true&freemail=true

    Show More Show Less
    17 mins
  • French Friday: The Problem with "Heritage Americans"
    Sep 25 2026

    Republican candidate Bo French in Texas created a controversy when he reacted to a photo of college students at the University of Texas football game. Many in the photo were of South Asian descent. He called it a "problem." David French (no relation) talks with Skye Jethani about the unmasked racism that MAGA has unleashed and what has led to the emergence of "heritage Americans" as a way of demoting immigrants and racial minorities. They also discuss the vacuum created efforts to diminish or remove American history from schools, and why overwhelming dissatisfaction with the two major political parties has failed to create a reform movement in the U.S.

    0:00 - Theme Song

    0:34 - Sports Catch-Up

    2:36 - Bo French's Open racism

    15:25 - 17 Million vs. 77 Million

    25:09 - "Heritage Americans"

    40:20 - Progressive Smugness

    48:50 - Why Do Third Parties Keep Failing?

    1:01:40 - End Credits

    David French on Bo French:

    https://www.nytimes.com/2026/09/17/opinion/bo-french-university-texas-longhorns.html

    Show More Show Less
    1 hr and 2 mins