Send us Fan Mail
Channel 4’s controversial ADHD documentary, The Great ADHD Myth?, has triggered anger, fear and widespread criticism across the ADHD community.
In this episode of ADHD Wise Podcast, Jannine Perryman and Dr Helen Wall bring together specialist ADHD practice, medicine, education and lived experience to examine what the programme claimed, what it left out and the real-world harm already following its broadcast.
Jannine is a consultant specialist teacher, psychoeducational ADHD coach, trainer and author who was diagnosed with ADHD at 41. Dr Helen Wall is a senior GP, menopause specialist, BBC Breakfast doctor and author of Menopause and ADHD.
Together, they ask whether The Great ADHD Myth? was genuinely a science-led investigation—or whether selective editing, flawed comparisons and a predetermined narrative misrepresented the evidence about ADHD, diagnosis and medication.
Jannine and Helen discuss:
• Why the absence of a definitive brain scan does not mean ADHD is not real
• The scientific and ethical concerns raised by the programme
• Dr. Max Pemberton’s ADHD assessment and portrayal of stimulant medication
• Why one dose cannot represent a properly supervised medication titration
• The risks of stopping or changing ADHD medication without medical guidance
• Why changing medication, sugar, screens, routines and parental support simultaneously proves very little
• The women and girls almost entirely missing from the documentary
• Late diagnosis, masking, medical misogyny and years of misdiagnosis
• Why increased demand for ADHD assessments was predictable
• NHS waiting lists, private providers and the cost of leaving ADHD unsupported
• The effect of the programme in schools, workplaces and families
• Why diagnosis can bring understanding and practical strategies, whether or not someone chooses medication
• How clinical evidence and lived experience should inform one another rather than being placed in opposition
This is not an argument against asking difficult questions about ADHD. Questions about assessment quality, access to treatment, medication and support matter. But serious questions require balanced evidence, scientific rigour and respect for the people whose lives are being discussed.
The law has not changed. An employer, teacher, colleague or family member cannot use a television documentary to dismiss somebody’s diagnosis, support needs or lived experience.
Most importantly: one sensationalist programme does not erase what you have lived through. Your experience remains real.
IMPORTANT: Do not stop, start or change prescribed ADHD medication without speaking to the clinician responsible for your care.
Find Dr Helen Wall:
Website: https://tvhealthdoctor.com/
Instagram: @doctorhelenwall
Book: Menopause and ADHD by Dr Helen Wall
Find ADHD Wise and explore our neurodiversity services:
https://adhdwise.uk
If this episode helps you, please subscribe, leave a comment or review, and share it with somebody who may need to hear it. Every interaction helps these conversations reach someone who may still believe they are alone.
Support the show
https://www.linkedin.com/company/adhdwiseuk/
https://www.tiktok.com/@adhdwiseuk?is_from_webapp=1&sender_device=pc
https://www.facebook.com/adhdwiseuk
https://www.instagram.com/adhdwiseuk/
https://www.youtube.com/@ADHDWisePodcast
https://www.adhdwise.uk