Season's Savings | ₹5/mo for 3 months

₹199/month after first 3 months. Renews automatically. Terms apply.
Talking Wise | Supply Chain & Business Growth cover art

Talking Wise | Supply Chain & Business Growth

Talking Wise | Supply Chain & Business Growth

Written by: Talking Wise | Supply Chain & Business Growth
Listen for free

About this listen

Business growth, supply chain, and logistics are at the heart of Talking Wise, the podcast about building a business without the wheels coming off. Explore the realities of self employment, practical operations management, and what it takes to scale with confidence.


© 2026 Talking Wise | Supply Chain & Business Growth
Economics
Episodes
  • EP 34. "Breaking down the Right to Substitute"
    Nov 10 2026

    Dive deep into the world of the right to substitute so you know you’re navigating the clause correctly.

    In this episode, Dan Richards (Deputy Chief Executive) and Darryl Oung share essential insights on the right to substitute. Darryl has supported businesses engaging with self-employed workers for over ten years, making him the perfect expert alongside Dan, who has worked alongside logistics businesses for six years.

    We talk about the key frameworks behind a compliant right to substitute.
    You’ll learn:

    ✨ Contracts vs. reality on the ground - Having a contract in place is essential, but if it doesn’t match daily operations, HMRC can argue it’s a “paper clause”
    ✨ Unfettered substitution - How to navigate substitution rights in line with UK regulations and industry compliance rules (like CSCS cards and CPC checks)
    ✨ The money trail - The correct invoicing and payment structures to use when a subcontractor sends a substitute
    Find more podcast events & resources: https://www.withwise.com/talking

    🔗 Connect with our guests:
    Dan Richards
    https://www.linkedin.com/in/d-richards/
    Darryl Oung
    https://www.linkedin.com/in/darryl-oung-4b07341a/


    ⏱️ Chapters:
    0:00 Teaser
    1:08 Introduction
    2:20 Paper clause vs genuine operational substitution
    5:08 Why written substitution clauses fail HMRC challenges and how personal service is tested
    14:55 What is an unfettered right of substitution under UK tax law?
    17:48 Can a main contractor reject a subcontractor’s substitute for lacking a CSCS card?
    19:53 Does requiring a subcontractor to have set qualifications such as CPC or site safety inductions invalidate a substitution clause?
    20:58 How can logistics companies enforce driver vetting without breaking self-employment?
    22:05 Who is legally required to pay a substitute worker - the client or the subcontractor?
    29:25 Does direct payment to a substitute driver trigger an employment relationship?
    32:24 How should invoicing be structured when a self-employed subbie uses a substitute?
    33:15 Why commercial liability for a substitute worker proves self-employed status
    33:53 The money trail: yes or no quick-fire questions

    Show More Show Less
    41 mins
  • Episode 33: Wise Answers | The right to substitute
    Nov 3 2026

    Learn what the right to substitute is and how to apply it in practice so you don’t get an unexpected visit from HMRC.

    In this episode, Dan Richards, Deputy Chief Executive of Wise, is in the hot seat, being questioned on one of the three core pillars of self-employment status. Drawing on six years of experience working directly with the logistics sector, Dan shares the exact operational best practices you need to maintain genuine self-employed working relationships.

    We break down how to bridge the gap between written contractual clauses and the realities of day-to-day depot or site work. You'll learn:

    ✨Right to substitute fundamentals - What the right of substitution actually means, why HMRC prioritises it during status reviews, and how it proves personal service is not required

    ✨The right to substitute in practice - How to apply substitution clauses in your day-to-day operations without compromising SLAs

    ✨ Myth-busting: 3 common scenarios - We analyse three real-world substitution scenarios to test whether they are truly compliant or an HMRC red flag.

    Find more podcasts at: https://www.withwise.com/talking

    🔗 Connect with our guests:

    Dan Richards: https://www.linkedin.com/in/d-richards/

    Chloe Eaton: https://www.linkedin.com/in/chloe-eaton-0b751392/

    ⏱️ Chapters:

    00:00 Trailer

    01:10 Episode introduction

    02:22 Understanding the right to substitute

    02:47 What is the right to substitute for self-employed workers?

    04:22 Does a self-employed subcontractor have to provide a substitute?

    05:09 Why is the right of substitution important for IR35 and status reviews?

    06:35 The right to substitute in practice

    06:41 Can a business reject a subcontractor's substitute on a construction site?

    09:25 Can a logistics company refuse a substitute driver?

    10:06 Who pays the substitute - the main business or the original subcontractor?

    11:06 What makes a right to substitution 'unfettered'?"

    12:00 Game: Wise or otherwise

    13:18 Is a right of substitution clause valid if a substitute was never actually sent?

    15:06 What happens if our contract says there's a right to substitute, but site managers don't allow it?

    16:28 Does using a pre-approved pool of workers invalidate the right to substitute?

    17:43 I make my self-employed subcontractors provide a substitute at times?

    19:37 Next steps on how to navigate the right substitute


    Show More Show Less
    24 mins
  • Episode 32: Mastering the lack of Mutuality of Obligation
    Oct 27 2026

    Discover why Mutuality of Obligation (MOO) matters, how to avoid costly HMRC challenges, and how to engage self-employed subcontractors with confidence.

    In this episode, Dan Richards, Darryl Oung, and Chloe Tierney-Martin break down one of self-employment's most critical, yet most misunderstood, pillars: the lack of Mutuality of Obligation.

    We unpack what MOO means in practice, how everyday working habits can quietly create legal liabilities, and what you can do straight away to get it right.

    You’ll learn:

    ✨ Mutuality of obligation and IR35 - What a lack of MOO actually means, and why it carries so much weight in IR35 and employment status decisions.


    ✨ Contracts vs reality - Why a “no obligation” clause isn’t enough on its own, and how repeated work offers can create an expectation of ongoing work.


    ✨ Daily habits that create obligation - Real examples of operational practices that silently tie you to offering or accepting work, and how to balance peak demand without creating them.


    ✨ Proving independence - How to evidence a lack of MOO in an HMRC enquiry, and the role financial risk and working for multiple contractors play.


    ✨ Consequences and training - The financial and legal penalties of getting it wrong, plus the guidelines to help your managers get it right.

    Tune in to stay compliant!

    Find more podcast events and resources: https://withwise.com/talking/

    -------

    🔗 Connect with our guests:

    Dan Richards: https://www.linkedin.com/in/d-richards/
    Darryl Oung: https://www.linkedin.com/in/darryl-oung-4b07341a/
    Chloe Tierney-Martin: https://www.linkedin.com/in/chloe-tierney-martin/
    -------

    ⏱️ Chapters:

    0:00 Teaser
    1:05 Introduction
    3:00 What a lack of Mutuality of Obligation means, and why it matters for IR35 and status
    7:07 Contracts: does a “no obligation” clause protect your business?
    11:25 When work is offered and accepted regularly: fixed-term engagements, ongoing expectations and IR35 risk
    14:28 Proving a lack of MOO in an HMRC enquiry
    15:40 Everyday habits that silently create an obligation to offer or accept work
    18:15 The operational impact of getting it wrong
    18:40 Why contract clauses fall short when depot practices tell a different story
    21:03 Balancing peak delivery demands without creating an expectation of ongoing work, and whose job it is to educate managers
    23:00 Financial risk, working for multiple main contractors and proving true independence
    28:40 The consequences of getting it wrong: how HMRC uses MOO in tribunals, and the financial and legal penalties
    30:22 Key operational guidelines for training managers on a lack of MOO
    33:18 How we help clients ensure a lack of MOO is present in their workforce
    34:05 Wrapping up the episode

    Show More Show Less
    35 mins
adbl_web_anon_alc_button_suppression_t1
No reviews yet