Being cited by AI isn't the same as being chosen. Simon Young of Question.marketing talks with Pola Ariel of Stay Branded and Dr Jorge Raziel about how ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity and Google AI Overviews decide which businesses to recommend.
In this episode:
- Why a citation is the bibliography, not the recommendation
- The small inconsistencies that quietly knock you out
- A client result: 29 meetings in a month, 11 from AI search, from 20 visits (one unnamed client, as reported by Simon; figures quoted with permission; not a guarantee)
- Why AI-written content won't get you chosen
- Agentic commerce, and an AI agent that negotiated a hotel price
- Voice and local: when your customer just asks their phone
- What an AI visibility review shows
Notes on figures (audio can't show on-screen corrections):
- The 86% figure is from Peec AI's study of 500,000 business-focused prompts (April 2026), not all Google searches.
- The 15% figure is Google's, for daily searches it has never seen before (2023 data), not prompts typed into LLMs.
- The client figures are one unnamed client's results for one month, as reported by Simon, quoted with permission, not a guarantee.
- The "15 80% of new searches" line is garbled as spoken and is not a sourced figure.
- The "web searches down by 50% three months after first using ChatGPT" figure is unverified; we have not found a source for it.
- The "80 to 90 percent of businesses in the US" figure (20:22) is spoken by the guest; no source found, not a figure we have verified.
Watch on YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kS8FSBoZp6M
Find out what AI says about your business: https://question.marketing
Chapters
00:00 Search is changing: AI Overviews and fewer clicks
01:21 Agentic commerce and getting chosen
02:12 Cited vs recommended
03:13 The wild west and "hopium"
03:43 Third-party trust and consistency
06:11 The 9 to 12 month window
06:41 Local AI results and natural language
07:41 Why AI traffic converts: 20 visits, 11 meetings
09:27 Why AI-written blogs won't get you chosen
10:05 Your internal knowledge is what AI wants
11:41 How quickly results show
12:12 No guarantees: every AI surface is different
13:07 Maintenance still matters
15:01 The most exciting time in search
16:07 A third big shift in technology
17:11 Agentic commerce: the hotel negotiation
18:26 Agents that shop for you
20:00 What this means for small businesses
22:04 Hyper-local, personalised answers
23:32 Find the knowledge gaps
24:42 Matching the work to the business
25:24 "My business is all relationships"
27:01 Ask your phone: the driving instructor example
27:42 What an AI visibility review shows
29:18 How to get an AI visibility review